The High Court held that four years’ delay in a summary prosecution breached the constitutional right to a hearing within a reasonable time and ordered that the trial be completed by a fixed date or the charges stayed; the President dissolved the Twelfth Parliament and the Regional Democratic Councils and appointed 1 September 2025 for the elections, the Elections Commission approved six national lists of candidates, and a new practice direction set out how the High Court works during the vacation.
The constitutional calendar turned decisively in July 2025. By Proclamation No. 1 of 2025, given on 3 July and published that day, the President, acting under articles 70(2) and 61 of the Constitution, dissolved the Twelfth Parliament, which had been summoned by proclamation dated 28 August 2020, with effect from 4 July 2025, and appointed 1 September 2025 as the day for the election of members of the National Assembly. Article 61 requires that election to be held within three months after dissolution. By Proclamation No. 2 of 2025, made under article 73(2), the President dissolved the ten Regional Democratic Councils on the same day and appointed 1 September for the regional elections.
Dissolution has practical consequences that are sometimes overlooked. Until the new National Assembly meets, no Act of Parliament can be passed, although subsidiary legislation and commencement orders may still be made under Acts already on the statute book, as several later in the year were.
The Guyana Elections Commission moved at once. On 3 July its Chairman, Justice of Appeal (Ret’d) Claudette Singh, made the National Registration (Suspension of Registration) Order 2025, Order No. 35 of 2025, suspending from 1 July to 14 September 2025 the continuous registration period under section 6(1A)(a) of the National Registration Act, as amended by Act No. 26 of 2022, which would otherwise have run from 1 July to 30 November. The revised list of electors was published the same day.
On 23 July the Commission gave notice under section 19 of the Representation of the People Act of the approved lists of candidates for the general election, in the national top-up, geographical constituency and regional categories. Six lists were approved for the national top-up: A Partnership for National Unity, the Alliance for Change, the Assembly for Liberty and Prosperity, Forward Guyana Movement, the People’s Progressive Party/Civic and We Invest in Nationhood, each with a designated presidential candidate. Amended notices later in the month recorded changes to the national top-up lists of A Partnership for National Unity, We Invest in Nationhood and the Alliance for Change. The Commission also gave notice of the appointment of ballot officers for non-resident electors and of the display of the non-resident electors’ roll.
For the courts, July began with the Court Vacation Practice Direction 2025, Practice Direction No. 1 of 2025, made on 30 June by the Chancellor of the Judiciary (ag.), Justice Yonette Cummings-Edwards, under section 34 of the High Court Act, and published on 1 July. It applies during the vacation from 1 July to 31 August each year. Criminal trials continue, and listed urgent matters are heard: applications concerning detention, bail, injunctions, stays of execution, decrees absolute, admiralty, insolvency, the anti-money laundering legislation, habeas corpus, child protection, interception of communications and, notably for an election year, matters relating to national, regional and local government elections. Other matters require an application within the existing case, supported by affidavit evidence of urgency, and urgent applications must be notified to the Registrar or Deputy Registrar in writing.
The direction’s treatment of time is its most useful feature. Time for filing or serving a statement of case, other than a statement of claim or fixed date application, does not run during the vacation unless the court directs otherwise. An originating process may be filed and served during the vacation, but time for the next step begins only after it ends. Time for appealing a decision given before or during the vacation also stops running until 1 September. The direction gives worked examples of each rule, which every litigation diary should reflect.
From the Guyana Courts
On 17 July, in Benn v Attorney General of Guyana (Action No. 2022-HC-DEM-CIV-SOC-317), Corbin-Lincoln J declared that the right of a former Commissioner of the Guyana Lands and Surveys Commission to a hearing within a reasonable time, guaranteed by article 144(1) of the Constitution, had been breached in the prosecution of three summary charges of misconduct in public office laid against him in March, April and May 2021. More than four years later the trial was incomplete. The mode of trial was not settled until March 2023, the prosecution’s statements were not filed until April 2023, the trial began only in January 2024, and by the hearing in April 2025 three of some fourteen witnesses had been called.
Applying the factors identified in Barker v Wingo and the framework set out by the Caribbean Court of Justice in Harewood v Attorney General [2024] CCJ 19 (AJ) BB, the judge held that a delay of about four years in summary proceedings was presumptively unreasonable, and that it was attributable mainly to the State rather than to the accused. She identified absences of the prosecution; some eight months of “judicial ping-pong” between a magistrate and the Chief Magistrate over recusal; about ten months in which the mode of trial waited on a copy of a High Court decision which, she observed, the magistrate could have obtained through her own efforts; the late filing of statements; and repeated adjournments for which no reason was recorded. The covid-19 pandemic did not explain the delay, since the criminal courts had continued to sit throughout. Evidence of specific prejudice was not a necessary ingredient of a breach.
On remedy, the judge accepted, following Gibson v Attorney General [2010] CCJ 3 (AJ), that a permanent stay is within the range of remedies for unreasonable delay but is not the inevitable one where a fair trial remains possible, and she declined to stay the charges outright. Nor would a bare declaration suffice, since it would not prevent the infringement from continuing. She therefore ordered that, unless the trial was completed by 20 October 2025, all the charges would be permanently stayed, framing the order to allow for acts of God or exceptional circumstances.
The judgment is a careful application of the Harewood framework to the magistrates’ courts, and its time-limited order offers a middle course between a bare declaration and an immediate stay. Its insistence that all State actors, including the courts themselves, bear the duty to organise and resource the system so that reasonable time standards are met will be read closely by those who prosecute and defend summary charges. The sequel is noted in the November docket.
Two rulings in July cleared the way for the elections. On 15 July George CJ (Ag) dismissed a challenge to the President’s confirmation of Clifton Hicken as Commissioner of Police in December 2024, after he had passed the age of fifty-five. The applicant accepted that an acting appointment beyond that age was permissible, but argued that a substantive appointment had to be made before it. As reported, the Chief Justice held that nothing in the Constitution or the Constitution (Prescribed Matters) Act prohibits the appointment of a Commissioner over fifty-five, and awarded costs to the State and to the Commissioner. The decision follows her ruling of February 2024 upholding his extension in office, noted in that month’s docket.
At the end of the month the Chief Justice dismissed two challenges to the electoral system. Christopher Ram sought a declaration that article 160(2)(a) of the Constitution entitles individuals to stand, and to be elected, as independent candidates in the geographical constituencies; Vishnu Bandu, leader of the United Republican Party, contended that provisions of the Representation of the People Act unconstitutionally restricted his right under article 147 to participate in elections. As reported, the Chief Justice found that both applications lacked merit and disclosed no constitutional breach in the manner in which political parties are required to contest national elections on lists. Costs of $500,000 were awarded against each applicant.
The account of the Benn case is taken from the written judgment. The accounts of the other rulings are taken from press reports and official statements and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located for them. Nothing here comments on the merits of any of these matters.
Also this month
The Civil Aviation (Security) Regulations 2025, Regulations No. 8 of 2025, published on 31 July, set out the framework for national civil aviation security, quality control, training and facilitation programmes, the role of the Director General, screener certification and the national committees.
In the Caribbean Court of Justice, Mr Justice Winston Anderson was sworn in as the Court’s fourth President on 6 July in Montego Bay, Jamaica. On 30 July, in CGI Consumers’ Guarantee Insurance Co Ltd v Stevenson [2025] CCJ 11 (AJ) BB, the Court held that the insurer of the owner and driver of a motor vehicle must satisfy a judgment obtained against its insured by a third party, a decision of interest to motor insurers and claimants here.
