Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

Gaskin and the Stabroek Licence, a Timetable at The Hague and Two Laws Brought Into Force

June 2024

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The Caribbean Court of Justice upheld the grant of the Liza petroleum production licence to all three Stabroek co-venturers, the International Court of Justice fixed the timetable for the second round of pleadings in the boundary case, and commencement orders for the trafficking and single window statutes were published.

On 27 June the Caribbean Court of Justice delivered judgment in Gaskin v Minister of Natural Resources [2024] CCJ 14 (AJ) GY, with ExxonMobil Guyana Ltd, CNOOC Petroleum Guyana Ltd and Hess Guyana Exploration Ltd as added respondents. The appellant had challenged the Minister’s grant in June 2017 of a petroleum production licence for the Liza 1 project in the Stabroek Block to all three co-venturers, when only Exxon, as operator, held an environmental permit from the Environmental Protection Agency.

Delivering the judgment of the Court, Mr Justice Anderson emphasised that articles 25, 36 and 149J of the Constitution place protection of the environment on an exalted plane, and that the Environmental Protection Act must be read in that light. He held that environmental authorisation is a condition precedent to the Minister’s power under section 35 of the Petroleum (Exploration and Production) Act to grant a production licence. But the licence was not invalid. The permit had been granted to the sole operator of the project, which alone was able to discharge the developer’s obligations; it was consistent with industry practice for the operator to act for the joint venture, with the other co-venturers included in the licence as financial partners; the co-venturers were jointly and severally liable for environmental harm; and including Hess and CNOOC in the licence did not increase the risk to the environment. The President and Madame Justice Rajnauth-Lee wrote concurring judgments, the latter observing that the Act did not contemplate a multiplicity of applications for the same project.

The appellant had also complained that the High Court had taken 366 days to deliver judgment. The Court held that the time limits in the Time Limit for Judicial Decisions Act are directory rather than mandatory, so that delay, though not to be condoned, did not invalidate the judgments below. The appeal was dismissed, and, because the appellant had acted as a public-spirited citizen seeking to advance the constitutional protection of the environment, each party bore its own costs. The judgment is now the leading statement of how Guyana’s environmental rights provisions bear on the interpretation of petroleum and environmental legislation.

Petroleum licensing is a matter of public and political debate, and nothing here comments on matters beyond the judgment itself.

On 14 June the International Court of Justice made an order in the case concerning the Arbitral Award of 3 October 1899 (Guyana v Venezuela). Following a meeting of the President of the Court with the parties’ agents on 11 June, at which both parties said a second round of written pleadings was necessary, the Court authorised a Reply by Guyana and a Rejoinder by Venezuela and fixed 9 December 2024 and 11 August 2025 as the respective time-limits. Guyana’s Reply is noted in the December docket.

The case remains before the International Court of Justice, and nothing here comments on its merits.

From the Guyana Courts

June produced three rulings of public interest. On 21 June Younge J dismissed an application by a police detective sergeant for judicial review of the Director of Public Prosecutions’ decision to discontinue private criminal charges he had laid against a senior police officer, complaining that the Director had not consulted him before doing so. The application failed, and he was ordered to pay costs. The decision is consistent with the breadth of the Director’s constitutional power to take over and discontinue private prosecutions.

On 24 June Morris-Ramlall J ruled that ExxonMobil Guyana Limited and the Attorney General must be added as parties to an application by Sherlina Nageer for disclosure of the insurance policy and parent company guarantee for the Liza Phase 2 project, finding that the company had a clear interest in the outcome. The ruling is consistent with the Caribbean Court of Justice’s decision in May, discussed in that docket, that the Attorney General should be permitted to intervene in the Liza 1 appeal.

On 28 June George CJ (Ag) refused applications by a member of the People’s National Congress Reform for injunctions to halt the party’s congress, holding that there was insufficient evidence to justify restraining the internal elections. Courts are, rightly, slow to intervene in the internal affairs of political parties on the eve of a vote.

These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The Liza 2 disclosure proceedings then remained before the High Court, and nothing here comments on their merits.

Also this month

The Combating of Trafficking in Persons Act 2023 (Commencement) Order 2024, Order No. 36 of 2024, published on 1 June, appointed 3 May 2024 as the day on which that Act came into operation. The Planning and Development Single Window System Act 2023 (Commencement) Order 2024, Order No. 39 of 2024, published on 8 June, brought the single window statute for planning and building approvals into operation with effect from 10 May 2024. In both cases the orders were published after the date of commencement, which is a point worth checking in any matter that turns on conduct in the intervening weeks.

The University of Guyana (Amendment) Order 2024, Order No. 43 of 2024, published on 27 June, enlarged the University Council from twenty-six to thirty-two members, adding among others a youth representative and a nominee of the Federation of Independent Trade Unions of Guyana. On 20 June the Guyana Elections Commission gave notice of the publication of the preliminary list of electors and of the claims and objections exercise, with a qualifying date of 30 June 2024.

In Attorney General of Belize v Gabourel [2024] CCJ 13 (AJ) BZ, decided on 26 June, the CCJ dealt with land compulsorily acquired in 2007 whose owner learned of the acquisition only in 2019. Rather than send the assessment back to the High Court, as the Court of Appeal had ordered, the CCJ itself awarded compensation of BZD4,545,325, with interest at six per cent a year from the date of acquisition. Given the number of acquisition orders made in Guyana during the year, the judgment’s treatment of delay and interest will interest landowners here.