The High Court held the teachers’ strike lawful and the right to strike constitutionally protected, the President appointed the chair and members of the Constitution Reform Commission, and Venezuela filed its Counter-Memorial at the International Court of Justice; the Caribbean Court of Justice ruled on a utility’s right to recover old arrears, and new petroleum licensing regulations were made.
The Official Gazette of 6 April 2024 published the instruments constituting the Constitution Reform Commission under the Constitution Reform Commission Act 2022. By Seal No. 20 of 2024, dated 3 April, the President, acting under section 4(2) of the Act and in his own deliberate judgment, appointed Justice Carl Ashok Singh as Chairperson of the Commission. Seals Nos. 21 to 37 of 2024, of the same date, appointed seventeen members under section 4(1)(a) and the following paragraphs of the Act, which provide for nominees of the parliamentary parties and of named constituencies, among them the Guyana Bar Association, the labour movement, the National Toshaos’ Council, the private sector, women’s and youth organisations, the Christian, Hindu and Muslim communities and farmers; the remaining members were sworn in later in the year. In May Parliament amended the Act to enlarge the Commission and to add a member nominated by the President, with retrospective effect; that amendment is noted in the May docket.
The Commission’s task under the Act is to review the Constitution, consulting as widely as possible, and to make recommendations for reform. Any amendment to the Constitution remains a matter for Parliament, and certain provisions can be altered only with a two-thirds majority or after a referendum. The appointment of the Commission was the first concrete step in a process whose outcome will depend on the proposals it receives and on what Parliament later does with its report.
Constitutional reform is a matter of public and political debate, and nothing here comments on the merits of any proposal.
On 8 April Venezuela filed its Counter-Memorial in the case concerning the Arbitral Award of 3 October 1899 (Guyana v Venezuela) at the International Court of Justice, within the time-limit fixed by the Court when it rejected Venezuela’s preliminary objection in April 2023. This was the first written pleading on the merits that Venezuela had lodged in the case. The filing meant that the case would proceed to a full determination of the validity of the 1899 Award and the definitive settlement of the land boundary, with or without a second round of written pleadings; the Court’s order of June on that question is discussed in the June docket.
The case remains before the International Court of Justice, and nothing here comments on its merits.
On 9 April the Caribbean Court of Justice delivered judgment in Che Jain Ping v Guyana Power & Light Inc [2024] CCJ 8 (AJ) GY. The utility had sued for arrears of $13,768,937 accumulated on a commercial account between 2002 and 2009, which it had transferred to another account held by the same customers, as regulation 23 of the Public Electricity Supply Regulations allows. The Court held that section 23 of the Electricity Sector Reform Act creates a statutory contract between consumer and supplier, that the words “without prejudice” in regulation 31(2) leave the utility free to sue for breach of that contract rather than only as a statutory claim, and that the utility’s standard terms and conditions provided the billing periods that permitted it to bill beyond twelve months. The appeal was dismissed. The decision confirms that a zero balance on one account is no answer to a claim where the arrears have been lawfully transferred elsewhere.
From the Guyana Courts
On 19 April, in a judgment delivered over several hours, Kissoon J gave judgment for the Guyana Teachers’ Union in its claim against the Government arising out of the February strike. As reported, he held that the strike was lawful, that the right to strike, like the right to bargain collectively, is embedded in the fundamental rights and freedoms protected by the Constitution, and that the Government could not deduct the pay of teachers who had taken part. He held that the decision to stop deducting and remitting union dues was arbitrary, unilateral and discriminatory, and found that the Government had failed to engage the union in collective bargaining over a multi-year salary proposal, criticising the Chief Labour Officer for concluding, without inquiry, that the conditions for conciliation had not been met.
The judgment is among the most significant statements on public sector industrial relations from the High Court in recent years, and its reasoning on a constitutional right to strike was immediately controversial. The Attorney General announced an appeal the same day, and it was filed in May; the Court of Appeal’s refusal in January 2025 to stay the order on union dues is noted in that month’s docket.
Earlier in the month, on 8 April, Navindra Singh J declared valid the special elections of the Guyana Public Service Co-operative Credit Union held on 2 March, and ordered that the twelve persons elected be permitted to take office without further delay, bringing to an end, for the time being, a long dispute over control of the credit union.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; the written judgment in the teachers’ case has not been located. The State’s appeal remains before the Court of Appeal, and nothing here comments on its merits.
Also this month
The Guyana Energy Agency (Petroleum and Petroleum Products) Regulations 2024, Regulations No. 3 of 2024, published on 27 April, replaced the 2014 regulations with a comprehensive licensing regime for retail, wholesale, import, export, storage, consumer installation and bulk transportation licences. They define “bulk quantity” as 2,000 litres or more, or 800 litres for liquefied petroleum gas, require information on beneficial owners, and provide that existing licences continue in force.
In Jacobs v The State [2024] CCJ 9 (AJ) GY, reasons for which were given on 11 April, the CCJ substituted a sentence of life imprisonment with eligibility for parole after twenty years in a case of murder for pay, matching the sentence previously imposed on the co-accused. The Court accepted the Director of Public Prosecutions’ concession of the appeal, and a separate opinion emphasised the prosecution’s duty to advocate openly where it considers a sentence too lenient. The Court also gave its reasons on costs in the Apsara Restaurants appeal on 19 April. The ICC Cricket World Cup West Indies Bill 2024, Bill No. 4 of 2024, was published on 29 April.
