The Rules Committee rewrote the procedure for sales in execution of judgments, the Caribbean Court of Justice explained what happens when the Full Court splits evenly, and the Court’s original jurisdiction enforced the Common External Tariff against Jamaica.
The development of January 2024 with the most immediate effect on everyday civil practice was the Civil Procedure (Amendment) Rules 2024, Rule No. 1 of 2024, made by the Rules Committee under sections 67 and 68 of the High Court Act and published in the Extraordinary Gazette of 15 January. The amendments concern Part 48 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2016 and the sale of property seized in execution of a judgment, an area in which judgment debtors had long complained that property was sold for far less than it was worth and judgment creditors had complained of sales that collapsed.
A new rule 48.10A requires the Registrar, before any sale, to obtain a valuation of the property from the Chief Valuation Officer, who is given fourteen days to provide it. If no valuation is forthcoming, the judgment creditor and then the judgment debtor are invited to supply one from an approved valuer. Rule 48.11 then sets a ladder of reserve prices. At the first sale the property may not be sold for less than the valuation. If it does not sell, the second sale may not be for less than the judgment sum; a third sale must realise at least 75 per cent of the judgment sum; and only at a fourth sale may the property go for whatever it fetches. Each later sale must be re-advertised at least ten days ahead.
For sales above $500,000, rule 48.14 introduces a structured payment regime. The purchaser must pay a 25 per cent deposit on the day of the sale, part in cash and the balance by manager’s cheque by 3 pm the next day, and may pay the remainder in three instalments carrying interest at six per cent. The instalments fall due over one, two and three months where the price is up to $5 million, and over two, four and six months above that figure. The rules provide for forfeiture where a purchaser defaults, with a right to make an urgent application within seven days and a requirement that the Registrar give the purchaser an opportunity to make representations first. Practitioners acting on either side of an execution should now build the valuation step, the reserve ladder and the instalment timetable into their advice on how long enforcement is likely to take and what it is likely to yield.
On 19 January the Caribbean Court of Justice delivered judgment in Jagdeo v Ferguson [2024] CCJ 2 (AJ) GY. The applicant, the defendant in libel proceedings in which default judgment had been entered, had appealed to a Full Court of two judges, who were evenly divided. The Court of Appeal then held that it had no jurisdiction because there was no appealable decision of the Full Court. By a majority, the CCJ held that section 75(2) of the High Court Act means that where the Full Court is evenly divided, the appeal is dismissed and the High Court decision stands as the decision of the Full Court, so that it is subject to the ordinary appeals regime under the Court of Appeal Act. Any other reading, the majority said, would leave the decision of a single judge beyond appellate review. Special leave was granted, the appeal allowed and the matter remitted to the Court of Appeal to consider leave, with the assessment of damages stayed. Mr Justice Barrow dissented. The procedural point will matter well beyond this case wherever a two-judge Full Court divides.
The libel claim itself remains before the courts, and nothing here comments on its merits.
From the Guyana Courts
January was a quiet month for decided cases, but two procedural rulings deserve notice. On 25 January the Full Court, Harnanan and Younge JJ, refused applications by the Guyana Public Service Co-operative Credit Union and members of its committee of management to stay an order made by Navindra Singh J on 15 December 2023 directing that a special general meeting of the credit union be held on 5 February. The members’ meeting went ahead, and with it the contest for control of the country’s largest credit union, which returned to the High Court in April.
The next day, in the challenge brought by Danuta Radzik to the Environmental Assessment Board’s decision upholding a waiver of an environmental impact assessment for the gas-to-energy facility at Wales, Ramlall J refused an application to strike out the claim. The applicant for striking out, a member of the Board, argued that the affidavit in support of the fixed date application had been sworn before the application itself was filed, contrary to rule 8.04 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2016. The judge held that the authority relied on did not apply, and the claim proceeded to be heard on its merits.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Both matters were then continuing, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
On 31 January the CCJ, in its original jurisdiction, decided DCP Successors Ltd v Jamaica [2024] CCJ 1 (OJ). It found that Jamaica had breached the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas by failing to apply the 40 per cent Common External Tariff to soap noodles imported from outside the Community, having found that the claimant’s noodles were capable of supplying the regional market; a further breach relating to certificates of origin was conceded. In Apsara Restaurants (Barbados) Ltd v Guardian General Insurance Ltd [2024] CCJ 3 (AJ) BB, delivered on 22 January after the death of Mr Justice Wit, the Court divided three to three on whether to adopt the Pan Atlantic test of materiality in insurance non-disclosure, so the law of Barbados was left unchanged; the insurer succeeded because the insured’s failure to disclose a previous unsuccessful claim was material.
The Appropriation Bill 2024, Bill No. 1 of 2024, was published on 15 January and the Fiscal Enactments (Amendment) Bill 2024, Bill No. 2 of 2024, on 26 January. Both were passed in February and are discussed in the February docket.
