The CCJ restored a High Court award of full pension benefits to a wrongfully dismissed chief executive. The ICJ heard Guyana's request for provisional measures against Venezuela's referendum. SOCU apologised to an attorney under a court order, the High Court ordered NIS to pay an old age pension despite an employer's failure to remit contributions, and small miners challenged a ministerial order closing their claims.
The Mental Health Protection and Promotion Act 2022 came into operation on 6 November under Order No. 71 of 2023. By the Small Business Lending Company (Designation) Order 2023 (Order No. 67, published 2 November), the Minister of Finance designated further approved small business lending companies, with the stated aim of strengthening support to the poultry sector.
In early November it was reported that the CCJ, by order dated 23 October 2023, had decided Arjoon v New Building Society Ltd and others (GYCV2023/002). The former chief executive of the New Building Society was dismissed in 2007, six months before he was due to retire. In 2017 the High Court (Reynolds J) found that he had been wrongfully dismissed and awarded him, among other things, full pension benefits. In September 2022 the Court of Appeal upheld the finding of wrongful dismissal but replaced the full pension award with a sum representing the pooled contributions. The CCJ heard the appeal and cross-appeal on 10 October 2023. By its order it allowed his appeal, dismissed the cross-appeal and restored the High Court's order. It reserved the question of severance pay and ordered a further $1,602,459 for leave pay and passage assistance for 2006 and 2007, with standard costs. The Court said reasons would follow; they were published in 2024 as [2024] CCJ 7 (AJ) GY, and this account draws on them and on press reports.
On 14 and 15 November the International Court of Justice heard Guyana's request for provisional measures against Venezuela's consultative referendum of 3 December. Guyana's Agent told the Court that the referendum sought national support for rejecting the Court's jurisdiction and annexing Essequibo. He said the Court "alone stands between" a lawful solution and chaos threatening the region. Venezuela's counsel said the referendum was an internal matter that was not meant to result in annexation and asked the Court to reject the request. On 28 November the Court announced that it would deliver its order on 1 December.
From the Guyana Courts
On 21 November SOCU's officers wrote to the attorney whose arrest in October 2022 the Chief Justice (ag) had held unconstitutional in July. They offered "an unequivocal apology", as the court's order had directed. The letter acknowledged that her rights to advise her client to remain silent and to consult the client in private had been violated. Press reports of 22 November said the Chief Justice (ag) had awarded her $700,000 in damages.
On 27 November Younge J ordered the National Insurance Scheme to pay an old age pension to a former carpenter who proved by letter and payslips that contributions had been deducted from his wages from 1992. The judge ordered NIS to credit him with 354 contributions that his employer had not remitted. She held that the applicant should not suffer for the failure of NIS and the employer to reconcile their records, or for the employer's failure to pay over his contributions.
It was reported on 28 November that two small-scale miners had applied to the High Court to quash a ministerial order (No. 53 of 2023), dated 8 August 2023 with retroactive effect from 1 March 2022, closing prospecting and mining in an area covering 32 gold claims they say they hold in the Mazaruni Mining District. They seek declarations of ownership and mandamus to compel processing of their claim licence applications.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of matters still pending.
Also this month
On 6 November the National Assembly passed a motion (Resolution No. 66) denouncing Venezuela's planned referendum and reaffirming the ICJ as the means of settling the controversy.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
