The CCJ held, by a majority, that a jury need not reject all of a witness's evidence because the witness lied on one point. The High Court dismissed challenges to the Liza 1 flaring permit and to the gas-to-energy pipeline permit. Guyana asked the ICJ for provisional measures against Venezuela's planned referendum on Essequibo. The Mental Health Protection and Promotion Act 2022 was brought into force.
By the Mental Health Protection and Promotion Act 2022 (Commencement) Order 2023 (Order No. 71, 31 October), the Minister of Health appointed 6 November 2023 as the day the Act came into operation. Under section 5 of the Condominium Act 2022, the Minister of Housing and Water declared on 11 October that the requirements of a condominium scheme had been satisfied and approved the proposed declaration and description for Esplanade Condos C and D at Plantation Peter's Hall, East Bank Demerara (Order No. 63, published 14 October). Two acquisition orders under the Acquisition of Lands for Public Purposes Act (Orders Nos. 68 and 69) were published on 31 October, following up the March orders for the Guyana Power and Light transmission line and the four-lane bypass highway route (Orders Nos. 26 and 27).
On 16 October the CCJ decided Fields v The State [2023] CCJ 13 (AJ) BB, a Barbados manslaughter appeal. An eyewitness had been shown to be untruthful in at least one respect. The trial judge told the jury they could reject that detail without necessarily rejecting the whole of his evidence. The appellant relied on the Barbados Court of Appeal's "Scantlebury direction": if the jury finds that a witness deliberately lied on oath, they must reject all of that witness's evidence. The majority held that the Scantlebury direction is not a proper direction. Questions of credibility and reliability are for the jury, which may disregard the untruthful parts and accept the rest if it thinks fit. The appeal was dismissed. Burgess J dissented. In his view the trial judge was bound by stare decisis to give the Scantlebury direction, and there was no sufficient basis for overruling it in this case.
On 30 October Guyana filed with the International Court of Justice a request for provisional measures in the case concerning the Arbitral Award of 3 October 1899. Guyana asked the Court to order Venezuela not to proceed with the consultative referendum planned for 3 December in its present form, and in particular not to include three of its five questions. It said the referendum aimed to support Venezuela abandoning the proceedings and annexing the territory in dispute, which comprises more than two-thirds of Guyana.
From the Guyana Courts
On 3 October the Chief Justice (ag) dismissed an application for judicial review of the EPA's May 2021 decision to modify the Liza 1 environmental permit. The modification governed flaring that was not routine and charged US$30 per tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent. The applicants contended that the modification breached the Environmental Protection Act and the polluter pays principle. The court found that they had abandoned several reliefs and adduced no evidence for the rest. It observed that the Act's adoption of the polluter pays principle recognises that some adverse effects will occur and must be paid for, and it criticised the applicants' evidence as opinion, read selectively.
On 5 October Sewnarine-Beharry J dismissed an application by two citizens to quash the EPA's permit for the pipeline component of the gas-to-energy project, after ExxonMobil Guyana and the Attorney General had been added as parties. The applicants argued that the permit was granted without evidence that the developer owned the land the pipeline crosses. In a written judgment the judge found no evidence that the applicants were personally aggrieved. She said judicial review "was never intended to be a sword for satisfaction but rather a shield against excesses of public functionaries", and held that a quashing order would disproportionately prejudice the developer and the State.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of matters still pending.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
