The Bail Act 2022 came into operation and the 2023 budget measures were published. The CCJ resentenced two brothers convicted of a contract killing and held that a former Attorney General can be sued personally for defamation. The High Court declined jurisdiction over the suspension of eight Opposition MPs.
The Bail Act 2022 (Commencement) Order 2023 (Order No. 1) appointed 4 January 2023 as the day the Bail Act 2022 came into operation. Five Acquisition of Lands for Public Purposes (Gas Pipeline Route) Orders (Nos. 3 to 7) were published the same day for the gas-to-energy project.
The budget followed. The Supplementary Appropriation (No. 3 for 2022) Bill (Bill No. 1) and the Appropriation Bill 2023 (Bill No. 2) were published on 13 and 16 January. The Income Tax (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Bill No. 3), published on 24 January, amends sections 8, 20, 36, 36A and 60 of the Income Tax Act to raise the income tax threshold from $900,000 to $1,020,000 a year. The Customs (Amendment of First Schedule) Order 2023 (Order No. 9), made under section 8 of the Customs Act and published the same day, reduced the duty on several motor car tariff headings from 45 per cent to 35 per cent. The Condominium Regulations 2022 (Regulations No. 1 of 2023) were published on 21 January, giving the Condominium Act 2022 its working detail.
On 17 January the CCJ gave judgment on sentence in Hinds v The State [2023] CCJ 1 (AJ) GY. The judgment of the Court was written by Barrow JCCJ. The brothers had been convicted of the murder of an elderly woman for payment, contrary to section 100(1)(d) of the Criminal Law (Offences) Act. The trial court imposed sentences of 81 years without parole for 45 years, which the Court of Appeal reduced to 50 years. The CCJ had dismissed the appeals against conviction at the hearing in October 2022, noting that the convictions rested mainly on the brothers' confessions. It now set aside the 50-year terms and imposed life imprisonment with eligibility for parole after 20 years, counting time on remand. The Court held that the minimum in section 100A(3) is mandatory, so mitigation cannot take a sentence below it.
On 24 January, in Williams v Kissoon [2023] CCJ 3 (AJ) GY, the CCJ refused a former Attorney General special leave to appeal, with costs. A former Deputy Solicitor General had sued him and the State newspaper over published words. The CCJ held that the State Liability and Proceedings Act does not prevent a servant of the State from being sued personally, so Mr Williams remains a defendant in his personal capacity. One member of the Full Court that had restored him to the claim was the claimant's brother-in-law. The CCJ said that judge ought to have recused himself, but that this did not decide the application.
Two other CCJ decisions came from outside Guyana. In Bynoe v The State [2023] CCJ 2 (AJ) BB (20 January) the Court gave reasons for refusing special leave in a Barbados case involving six murders. In Caye International Bank Ltd v Rosemore [2023] CCJ 4 (AJ) BZ (31 January) it held that a broadly worded clause in a bank's terms did not exclude the banker's Quincecare duty to refrain from executing a payment instruction where it has reasonable grounds to suspect fraud, and dismissed the bank's appeal.
From the Guyana Courts
In a ruling reported on 17 January, Younge J held that the High Court had no jurisdiction to hear the challenge by eight Opposition MPs to the Committee of Privileges report on which they were suspended in July 2022. She relied on article 165 of the Constitution, under which the National Assembly regulates its own procedure, and noted that the MPs had challenged the Committee's report but not the Standing Orders that created it. She found the case was not exceptional enough to justify enquiring into the internal proceedings of the Assembly. Four of the MPs had already completed their suspensions.
In the challenge by an Opposition MP to the delay in appointing a substantive Chancellor and Chief Justice, Younge J heard argument on 11 January and set her ruling for March. The applicant asked the court to order the President to begin consultation with the Leader of the Opposition under article 127 within two months; the Attorney General argued that the Constitution sets no timeline.
On 17 January the Court of Appeal refused a GECOM commissioner's motion to extend time to appeal a $2.5 million defamation judgment in favour of the current Chief Elections Officer, reportedly because the motion was nearly two years late and the appeal lacked merit. On 20 January Morris-Ramlall J reportedly dismissed a senior police officer's $70 million libel claim against the former Chairman of the Police Service Commission, reportedly because the claimant had not filed witness statements as ordered at case management.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of matters still pending.
Also this month
The Chief Justice (ag) and the Chancellor (ag) publicly called for a functioning Judicial Service Commission, citing a shortage of judges.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
