Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The CCJ Ends the Petition 99 Appeal, Local Government Elections Fixed for March 2023 and the Petition 88 Appeal Fast-Tracked

October 2022

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The CCJ held that Guyana's Court of Appeal had no jurisdiction to hear an appeal against the dismissal of Petition 99 of 2020 for late service, and criticised the premature release of its decision. Local government elections were fixed for 13 March 2023. The Court of Appeal agreed to hear the Petition 88 appeal urgently, and ExxonMobil's operating subsidiary was joined to a challenge to the Liza Phase 1 permit.

The Municipal and Neighbourhood Democratic Councils (Election Day) Order 2022 (Order No. 38, made 20 October) appointed 13 March 2023 as the day for electing councillors of the participating local authorities. Those authorities, with their seats and the division between proportional and constituency councillors, are listed in the Participating Local Authorities Order (Order No. 39) under section 38A of the Act. The Local Authorities (Elections) (Constituencies) Order 2022 (Order No. 40) and Orders amending the Mabaruma Town constitution and the local democratic organs' areas and councils (Orders Nos. 42 to 44) were published on 20 and 21 October. The Mandela–Eccles interlink was declared a public road (Order No. 41). Three sets of regulations under the Civil Aviation Act (Regulations Nos. 24 to 26) were published on 1 October, and the COVID-19 regulations were amended again on 17 October (Regulations No. 30).

On 19 October the CCJ allowed the appeal in Attorney General v Thomas [2022] CCJ 15 (AJ) GY. The Chief Justice (ag) had dismissed Petition 99 of 2020 because David Granger, a necessary party, was served after the five days allowed by section 8 of the National Assembly (Validity of Elections) Act and the Rules. By a majority, the Court of Appeal held that it had jurisdiction to hear the petitioners' appeal through article 123 of the Constitution and section 6(2) of the Court of Appeal Act. In a judgment delivered by Anderson JCCJ, with whom Wit and Rajnauth-Lee JJCCJ agreed, the CCJ held that article 163 and the election petition legislation create a comprehensive and exclusive regime for election challenges. Article 163(3) allows an appeal in only two circumstances, and a dismissal for want of proper service falls within neither. The special jurisdiction prevails over the general civil appellate jurisdiction. The Court left open an exception, with a very high threshold, where an appeal is needed to maintain the integrity of the Constitution, but nothing in this case approached it. Barrow and Jamadar JJCCJ concurred in the result for different reasons, considering that such an appeal lies to the Full Court rather than to the Court of Appeal. The parties bear their own costs.

In a statement of 20 October the CCJ criticised the publication of the result on the Attorney General's Facebook account before the judgment was delivered. The Court had sent advance copies of its decision to counsel in confidence, and it described the disclosure as "inexcusable".

From the Guyana Courts

On 3 October the Court of Appeal (Cummings C (ag), Gregory and Rishi Persaud JJA) granted an application to expedite the appeal against the Chief Justice's 2021 decision on Petition 88 of 2020. That petition seeks to set aside the results of the March 2020 elections for non-compliance with the Constitution and the electoral laws. The court rejected an objection that the appellants had waited 19 months to seek an urgent hearing and fixed 1 November for a report on the state of the record.

On 14 October the Full Court (Barlow and Kissoon JJ) declined, as premature, to consider the suspended Opposition MPs' appeal against Younge J's refusal of interim relief while the substantive case remained before her. About 19 October the High Court allowed Esso Exploration and Production Guyana Ltd to be joined to the application by two citizens to quash the renewal of the Environmental Protection Agency's permit for Liza Phase 1. The applicants contend that a fresh environmental impact assessment was required.

These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of matters still pending.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.