The CCJ held that a company whose shares are owned by more than fifty people is a "public company" that must register with the Guyana Securities Council, held by a majority that a director who personally commits an offence cannot hide behind his company, and confirmed the right of private prosecution. Number portability obligations came into force, and the Petroleum (Exploration and Production) (Amendment) Bill was published.
On 30 July the CCJ decided Trust Company (Guyana) Ltd v Guyana Securities Council [2021] CCJ 11 (AJ) GY. The company was incorporated as a private company. In 2010 the Council told it that, because it had more than fifty shareholders (sixty in 2009), it was a public company under the Securities Industry Act and had to register as a reporting issuer. Section 3(2)(f)(ii) includes in the definition of a public company one "that is the issuer of a security that is beneficially owned by more than fifty persons". The company argued that this caught only a single security owned by more than fifty people, and that section 56(1), which makes all public companies reporting issuers from the commencement of Part V, was a transitional provision.
Rajnauth-Lee JCCJ, for the Court, rejected both arguments and dismissed the appeal. Under the Interpretation and General Clauses Act the singular includes the plural, and "security" includes a share. The Act therefore uses a "numbers game" test: an issuer of shares beneficially owned by more than fifty persons is a public company. A company could not "hide behind the use of the singular term" to escape regulation designed to protect investors. Section 56(1) operates "from", not "as at", the commencement of Part V on 22 July 2002, so companies that become public afterwards are also reporting issuers.
In Delpeache v Commissioner of Police [2021] CCJ 10 (AJ) BB, decided the same day, the sole director of a boutique that sold counterfeit goods argued that the company, not he, should have been charged under the Trade Marks Act. By a majority of three to two (Anderson and Burgess JJCCJ dissenting), the Court dismissed his appeal. Barrow JCCJ held that "there is no support either in principle or in authority" for "a corporate veil in criminal law". An individual who personally commits criminal acts in conducting a company's business may be prosecuted, whether or not the company could also be. Wit and Rajnauth-Lee JJCCJ agreed that the doctrine of "piercing the corporate veil" has no place in the criminal law.
In Dottin's Academy Inc v Norville [2021] CCJ 8 (AJ) BB (reasons 1 July), the Barbados Court of Appeal had quashed convictions in what Barrow JCCJ called "simply a cuss-out case", on the ground that only the school's registered owner could lay the information. The CCJ held that the company was the informant in its own right and needed no authority from anyone to prosecute. It restored the conviction and sent the remaining grounds of appeal back to that court. In Maximea v Attorney General [2021] CCJ 9 (AJ) DM (19 July), the Court refused special leave to a former police officer whose complaints dated from before 2005, describing them as res judicata and long out of time.
The Telecommunications (Commencement of Number Portability Obligations) Order 2021 (Order No. 14, 1 July) brought into force on that day the number portability obligations of dominant operators under regulation 7(2)(b) of the Telecommunications (Interconnection and Access) Regulations 2020. The Petroleum (Exploration and Production) (Amendment) Bill 2021 (Bill No. 14, 27 July) would exclude State and Government land, land of State-controlled entities and reserves from section 52(1)(b), while allowing a licensee to use such land for pipelines with the Minister's consent. It was enacted in August. A Government Notice of 29 July announced the appointment of the Law Reform Commission under the Act as amended in February. Regulations No. 7 of 2021 (23 July) renewed the health and safety measures for airports and aircraft.
From the Guyana Courts
On 27 July Colwyn Harding's 2014 claims against the State and a police constable, over his alleged assault in custody at Timehri in 2013, stood dismissed before Navindra Singh J, and he was ordered to pay $2 million in costs. An earlier dismissal for want of prosecution had been recalled on condition that he paid costs by 16 July. According to a release from the Attorney General's office, he had not paid and did not appear. It is a reminder that conditions attached to the reinstatement of a claim are enforced strictly.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits.
Also this month
The twentieth COVID-19 Emergency Measures (29 July) required unvaccinated persons to make an appointment before entering Government buildings, a requirement that also applied to employees. Proclamation No. 2 of 2021 declared national days of mourning after the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse of Haiti on 7 July.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
