The Chief Justice dismissed the remaining election petition and upheld the recount Order, held that two Parliamentary Secretaries sit in the National Assembly unlawfully, the Court of Appeal set aside a 1982 conviction after a delay of almost forty years, and the CCJ held that a retired judge may sign a judgment of a case she heard.
April was a month of decisions rather than legislation. Apart from appointments and notices, the Gazette carried no Acts, Bills or significant Orders.
At the Caribbean Court of Justice, Knox v Deane [2021] CCJ 5 (AJ) BB (29 April) arose from a garnishee order that attached a judgment debtor's dividends from a family company to pay costs she owed. The procedural grounds failed. The judge had been right not to order service on third parties who claimed beneficial interests in the dividends, and the company was entitled as of right to withhold from the dividends what the debtor owed it. The appeal is more notable for its constitutional points. The Barbados Court of Appeal took four years to give judgment. By then one of the judges who heard the appeal had become Governor-General and another a judge of the CCJ, and both signed the judgment.
Saunders PCCJ held that section 84(2)(b) of the Barbados Constitution allows a former judge to deliver judgment in proceedings begun before her without re-appointment or a fresh oath. Separation of powers was not breached, because the Governor-General signed as a former judge and exercised no executive power. The Court nonetheless called the delay "serious and unacceptable". Jamadar JCCJ, concurring, suggested six months as the outer standard of reasonableness for delivering judgment. The decision is a reminder, for every court in the region, that delay is itself a question of constitutional rights.
From the Guyana Courts
On 13 April the Court of Appeal set aside the 1982 conviction of Donald Rodney for possession of explosives, and his sentence of eighteen months. His appeal had waited almost forty years to be heard, and the Director of Public Prosecutions conceded that the delay breached his right under article 144 of the Constitution to a fair hearing within a reasonable time.
On 20 April the Chief Justice (ag), on an application by the Opposition Chief Whip, Christopher Jones, declared that the two Parliamentary Secretaries, Sarah Browne and Vikash Ramkissoon, are not lawful members of the National Assembly. They had been candidates on the governing party's list but were not extracted from it as elected members, and were instead seated as non-elected members by virtue of their appointment. "They cannot be elected and non-elected members at the same time," the Chief Justice was reported to have said. She drew on Morean, the case in which the appointment of two elected members of the previous Government as technocratic ministers had been successfully challenged. The Attorney General filed an appeal the same day.
On 26 April the Chief Justice (ag) dismissed Petition 88P/2020, the remaining petition against the results of the March 2020 elections. She held that section 22 of the Election Laws (Amendment) Act and GECOM's Order No. 60 of 2020, under which the national recount was conducted, were intra vires and did not offend the Constitution. Article 162(1)(b) gave GECOM a mandate "very wide" enough to address the "undeniable difficulties" in the process. She also held that the statements of recount could and did replace the Returning Officers' original declarations, and that there was no breach by GECOM such as to make the elections "a sham". She directed that the Statements of Poll and of Recount remain in the court's custody until all appeals are decided. An appeal was filed in June.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of the matters under appeal.
Also this month
The seventeenth COVID-19 Emergency Measures were published on 30 April.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
