The Chief Justice declared one of the two election petitions from the March 2020 elections a nullity because the List leader was served out of time, the High Court quashed deportation orders made against 26 Haitian nationals, the borrowing limit under the Public Loan Act was raised to $500 billion, and the CCJ refused five Barbadian attorneys leave to join a case that was not theirs.
On 18 January the Chief Justice (ag), Roxane George, gave a written decision on the two petitions filed by supporters of APNU+AFC to challenge the results of the March 2020 general and regional elections. Petition 99P/2020, brought by Monica Thomas and Brennan Nurse, had been filed on 15 September 2020. Section 8 of the National Assembly (Validity of Elections) Act and rule 9 of its rules required the petition and the supporting papers to be served within five days, and the deadline in this case was 21 September. The Chief Justice found that the second respondent, David Granger, the Representative of the APNU+AFC List, was not served until 25 September. Supplementary affidavits filed later, without the court's permission, to say that he had been served on 18 September did not displace the acknowledgment of service that he had signed and dated 25 September.
The decision turned on two holdings. First, it is "an entrenched principle of election laws" that time limits must be strictly complied with. Second, the Representative of a List whose candidates won seats is a necessary party to a petition that would undo that allocation, even when the petitioners say they are seeking nothing against him. The Chief Justice declared the petition "a nullity" that "cannot proceed for procedural non-compliance as to service" and dismissed it with costs. In the same decision she held that the other petition, 88P/2020 by Claudette Thorne and Heston Bostwick, had been served in time and would proceed. An appeal against the dismissal of Petition 99 was later lodged.
The decision matters beyond the elections. Statutory deadlines for service in specialist jurisdictions are not like the case-management timetables of the Civil Procedure Rules. Missing one by four days ended the case before any question of merit was reached.
The Government made two Orders under the Interpretation and General Clauses Act and the Public Loan Act. The Declaration of Functions Order 2021 (Order No. 1, 11 January) deputes the Commissioner of the Guyana Lands and Surveys Commission to sign, on the President's behalf, leases, licences and permissions to occupy State lands under the State Grants (President's Signature) Act, and to approve their terms. The Public Loan (Increasing of Limit) Order 2021 (Order No. 2, 27 January) raises the limit on borrowing under section 2(1) of the Public Loan Act from $150 billion to $500 billion.
At the Caribbean Court of Justice, Bryan v Attorney General of Barbados [2021] CCJ 1 (AJ) BB (reasons delivered on 22 January) is short but pointed. A possession claim between two private citizens had been stalled for six years by a side dispute over whether one attorney's practising certificate was valid while her Bar subscription was unpaid, and whether the subscription requirement was constitutional. Five attorneys who were not parties then sought special leave to take that constitutional question to the CCJ. Wit JCCJ, for the Court, refused leave. Non-parties may be allowed to appeal only "in extraordinary circumstances". The Court said the profession had "hijacked" the parties' "simple dispute". Lawyers may challenge the Legal Profession Act, but "in a case brought by them … and not on the backs of ordinary citizens".
From the Guyana Courts
On 27 January the Chief Justice (ag) quashed deportation orders made against 26 Haitian nationals. According to the reports, she held that the orders breached natural justice because the Haitians had never been brought before a court as sections 16 and 28 of the Immigration Act contemplate. She also found breaches of their constitutional rights to personal liberty and freedom of movement, but refused to refer questions to the CCJ and refused damages.
Except where stated, these accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located for the Haitians' case. The account of Petition 99P/2020 is taken from the written decision. Nothing here comments on the merits of matters still pending.
Also this month
The COVID-19 Emergency Measures were amended on 13 January (No. 13) and replaced by a fourteenth set on 29 January, which was itself amended on 2 February.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
