Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

A National Curfew, the Recount Cleared and No Leapfrogging to the CCJ

April 2020

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The first COVID-19 Emergency Measures imposed a curfew and closed most businesses, the Court of Appeal cleared the way for a recount supervised by the Elections Commission, and the Caribbean Court of Justice held that an appeal cannot bypass a Court of Appeal that has not yet ruled.

On 3 April the Minister of Public Health published the first COVID-19 Emergency Measures, made under paragraphs (1) and (2)(b) of the President’s Direction of 16 March under the Public Health Ordinance. They took effect from that day for one month. Every person was to remain within the confines of his or her home and yard, except as the Notice permitted. Private parties, sporting events, banquets, bars and rum shops, the seawall, pools, creeks and rivers, gyms, salons, clubs and the meetings of societies and associations were closed to the public; weddings were limited to the couple, the witnesses and the marriage officer, and funerals to ten mourners. Visits to quarantine facilities, prisons and care homes were prohibited. A curfew was imposed throughout Guyana from 6:00 pm to 6:00 am until 3 May. Public servants and employees of statutory bodies and State-owned enterprises were to work from home. All services were closed except listed essential services, including hospitals and pharmacies, utilities, the disciplined forces, the Revenue Authority and the two river bridges, which might operate around the clock; banks, markets, supermarkets, gas stations and restaurants for delivery and take-away might open from 6:00 am to 5:00 pm; and any other business might continue only if its employees could work exclusively from home.

A second set of Measures was published on 9 April and amended on 20 April, and on 29 April a third set of Measures continued the regime into May. For employers the Measures raised questions that the Notices did not answer, among them whether an enforced closure frustrated contracts of employment or supply, and how far force majeure clauses in commercial contracts would respond to a closure ordered by the State. The Measures were enforced through prosecutions in the magistrates’ courts, and their reach was the subject of the habeas corpus application noted below.

On 6 April the President of the Caribbean Court of Justice issued Practice Direction 1 of 2020, the COVID-19 Emergency Directions, under the Court’s Appellate and Original Jurisdiction Rules. The Court would hear only matters that were urgent or otherwise fit for adjudication, after consultation with the parties; time limits for filing might be varied on written application; and hearings would be held virtually, with attorneys dressed as for chambers. Reserved judgments would be delivered as and when ready. The Court had already moved to remote working, and would hear the Guyana elections appeal in July in this way.

On 3 April the Court delivered judgment in Knox v Deane [2020] CCJ 5 (AJ) BB. The applicant’s appeal from a High Court order in long-running litigation over Kingsland Estates had been heard in the Court of Appeal of Barbados, which reserved judgment in 2016 and had not ruled. He asked the CCJ to treat the delay as a dismissal and to hear his appeal directly. The Court held that, unless Parliament provides otherwise, its appellate jurisdiction extends only to decisions of the Court of Appeal, so that it could not hear an appeal from the High Court. It acknowledged that a delay of over four years in deciding whether a garnishee order was rightly made “borders on the intolerable”, but observed that the applicant was not without remedy: he could seek constitutional redress under section 24(1) of the Constitution of Barbados.

From the Guyana Courts

On 5 April the Court of Appeal, by a majority, allowed in part the appeal of Ulita Moore against the Full Court’s decision of 31 March. Gregory JA, with whom Reynolds JA agreed, held that the High Court had a narrow constitutional jurisdiction to review whether the Guyana Elections Commission had ceded its supervisory function under article 162(1)(b) of the Constitution to a CARICOM team, and granted a declaration that any arrangement removing supervision of the recount from the Commission would be unlawful. But the injunctions halting the recount were not reinstated, and the matter was not remitted to the High Court. Persaud JA would have dismissed the appeal entirely. Consequential orders were issued on 7 April. The Commission was therefore free to proceed with a recount that it conducted and supervised itself, with CARICOM observing; the order giving effect to that decision is discussed in the May docket.

On 2 April Reynolds J refused an application by way of habeas corpus for the release of a Guyanese student who had been placed in a State quarantine facility on arrival from Barbados. The applicant contended that he had not been tested, that the quarantine order applied only to persons who had tested positive, and that the conditions of the facility breached his fundamental rights. The application was the first test in the courts of the State’s quarantine powers in the pandemic.

These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of either matter.

Also this month

A notice of the Minister of Public Health published on 29 April, made under the President’s Direction, announced that a National Sanatorium for the care and treatment of COVID-19 patients would be constructed at the Ocean View Hotel, Liliendaal, and the Acquisition of Lands for Public Purposes (National Sanatorium) Order 2020, Order No. 59 of 2020, published the same day, declared the construction a public work under the Acquisition of Lands for Public Purposes Act, Cap. 62:05.

April was the month in which the pandemic and the electoral dispute became intertwined, with the courts working remotely to resolve the second while the first shut the country down.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.