The Court of Appeal held that residence in Guyana is not a condition of registration as an elector, the Land Surveyors (Profession) Act 2014 was brought into force, and a divided Caribbean Court of Justice upheld a murder conviction resting on identification evidence.
By the Land Surveyors (Profession) Act 2014 (Commencement) Order 2020, Order No. 3 of 2020, published on 26 February, the Minister appointed 25 February 2020 as the day on which the Land Surveyors (Profession) Act 2014, Act No. 4 of 2014, came into operation. The Act had waited almost six years for commencement. It places the profession of land surveying on a statutory footing, with provision for the licensing and discipline of surveyors. For conveyancers, lenders and anyone dealing in land, the reliability of the survey plan is the foundation of the title, and a regulated profession is a safeguard for every transaction that depends on one.
From the Guyana Courts
On 10 February the Court of Appeal, comprising the Chancellor (Ag), Yonette Cummings-Edwards, and Justices of Appeal Rishi Persaud and Dawn Gregory, unanimously affirmed the 2019 ruling of George CJ (Ag) that residence is not a requirement for registration as an elector. The appeal was brought by the Attorney General in Attorney General v Ram, with the Guyana Bar Association appearing as amicus curiae. The Attorney General had argued that a residency requirement was restored by the Constitution (Amendment) Act No. 4 of 1991. As reported, the Court held that the 1991 amendment was transitional legislation made for a particular period and was spent, so that the residency requirement removed by the 1980 Constitution had not revived. It followed that persons could not lawfully be removed from the National Register of Registrants unless they had died or become disqualified under article 159(2), and then only in compliance with the National Registration Act. With elections three weeks away, the ruling settled that the list would not be purged of electors living abroad.
In February the Chief Justice (Ag) dismissed the application by Ramon Gaskin for judicial review of the grant on 15 June 2017 of the petroleum production licence for the Liza development. Mr Gaskin contended that Hess and CNOOC Nexen, as co-venturers with Esso, each required an environmental permit before the licence could be granted. The Chief Justice held that the permit issued to Esso as operator satisfied the requirements of the Environmental Protection Act, that the Minister had properly exercised his discretion, and that the licence covered all three contracting parties. Mr Gaskin filed an appeal; the Court of Appeal’s decision, and the later decision of the Caribbean Court of Justice, are discussed in the June 2024 docket.
On 25 February Persaud J (Gino Persaud) refused an application by the Minister within the Ministry of Communities, Annette Ferguson, for interim injunctions restraining the Leader of the Opposition and the Guyana Times from repeating statements that she owned three plots of land. Applying the long-established rule that an interim injunction will not be granted in defamation where the defendant intends to plead justification or fair comment, the judge held that the case was not one of the rare exceptions. The libel claims themselves continued.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The libel claims then continued before the High Court and the Gaskin appeal was pending, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
On 14 February the Caribbean Court of Justice dismissed, by a majority of three to two, the appeal in Hall v The Queen [2020] CCJ 1 (AJ) BB, a murder conviction from Barbados resting on the evidence of an eyewitness. The lead judgment was given by Anderson JCCJ. The issues were the duty of a trial judge under section 102 of the Barbados Evidence Act to withdraw from the jury a case that depends on identification evidence unless there are special circumstances or supporting evidence, and the consequence of the failure to give a good character direction to which the accused was entitled. Barrow and Jamadar JJCCJ dissented, holding that the case should have been withdrawn from the jury; Jamadar JCCJ added that Caribbean courts should take account of the scientific research on the fallibility of eyewitness evidence. Although the case is from Barbados, the judgments are a rich source on identification evidence, a recurring issue in Guyana’s criminal courts.
On the same day the Court dismissed the appeal in Shillingford v Andrew [2020] CCJ 2 (AJ) DM, the second appeal from Dominica arising out of a family dispute over land, holding that there were no exceptional circumstances justifying a review of concurrent findings of fact by the courts below.
The month thus ended with the register settled and polling day a week away.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
