The High Court quashed the Local Government Commission's dismissal of the Georgetown Town Clerk for unlawful delegation. It also upheld an insurer's avoidance of a motor policy for misrepresentation and non-disclosure. GECOM ordered a revision of the registers with a qualifying date of 31 December 2019.
GECOM made two orders under the National Registration Act. The National Registration (Residents) Order 2019 (Order No. 70), published on 26 September with an addendum the next day, requires registers of electors to be prepared for each registration area with 31 December 2019 as the qualifying date. The National Registration (Claims and Objections) Order 2019 (Order No. 72), made on 30 September, provides for claims and objections with the same qualifying date. Earlier in the month the GECOM secretariat had put forward a proposal for elections in March 2020. The three months from the CCJ's 18 June judgment ended on 18 September, and the Opposition filed further proceedings seeking compliance with article 106.
From the Guyana Courts
On 13 September Morris-Ramlall J quashed the Local Government Commission's decision to dismiss the Town Clerk of Georgetown. The Commission had acted on the report of a commission of inquiry it had appointed. The judge held that article 74A of the Constitution and sections 14 and 19 of the Local Government Commission Act did not empower the Commission to delegate its investigative powers to an outside body. In doing so it "committed an error of law and made an unlawful delegation". She also quashed the appointment of the commission of inquiry. Reinstatement was not appropriate, because the Town Clerk's administrative leave had not been challenged, so the position returned to the status quo when he was sent on administrative leave in September 2018.
In Sahadeo v Diamond Fire & General Insurance Inc [2019] GLR 312 (3 September), Harnanan J dismissed a claim for $7.5 million under a motor policy. The car had been imported used and damaged and was written off within three weeks of being insured. The claimant had represented that it was in good repair and had never been in an accident. She had also not disclosed that the principal of the dealer who imported and sold the car was her brother-in-law. The judge restated the duty of utmost good faith that each party to an insurance contract owes the other. The claimant, a professional accountant, should have appreciated the importance of answering the proposal form truthfully and of making reasonable inquiries before signing it. The insurer was entitled to avoid the policy for material non-disclosure and misrepresentation.
The account of Sahadeo is taken from the report at [2019] GLR 312. The account of the Town Clerk's case and of the further election proceedings is taken from press reports and has not been verified against a written judgment.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
