In its consequential orders the CCJ declined to fix an election date and said the Government should act as a caretaker. The Court of Appeal struck down the part of section 219 of the Customs Act that let the Comptroller choose the penalty. A new GECOM Chairman was appointed, and new enforcement rules under the CPR were gazetted.
On 19 July the Civil Procedure (Amendment) Rules 2019 were gazetted. The Rules Committee, chaired by the Chancellor (ag), made them on 30 June. They replace Parts 43 to 53 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2016 with a new code on the enforcement of judgments. The new code covers garnishment, writs of possession, delivery, sequestration and seizure and sale, and a new Part 48A on the sequestration and sale of plantations in cultivation. It also covers receivers, committal and contempt, examination in aid of execution, and stop notices and charging orders. The Food Safety Act 2019 (Act No. 19) was gazetted the same day. The Restorative Justice Bill 2019 and an Adoption of Children (Amendment) Bill were published on 8 July.
On 29 July, by an instrument made under article 161(1) and (2) of the Constitution (Seal No. 147 of 2019), the President appointed Claudette Singh SC, a former Justice of Appeal, as Chairman of the Elections Commission with effect from that day. The press reported that the appointment followed agreement between the President and the Leader of the Opposition.
On 12 July the CCJ made its consequential orders. In the no-confidence appeals, Ram v Attorney General; Jagdeo v Attorney General; Persaud v Reid [2019] CCJ 14 (AJ), it declared that article 106(6) and (7) apply to a no-confidence motion and that 33 votes are a majority of the 65-member Assembly. The member whose vote carried the motion was ineligible to be elected because of his Canadian citizenship, but his vote was valid, and nothing in the anti-defection provision of article 156(3) prevented him from casting it as he did. The Assembly had properly passed the motion on 21 December 2018, and article 106 was immediately engaged. The Court observed that an election should have been held by 21 March 2019 unless the Assembly had extended the period by a two-thirds resolution, which it had not done. It was not, however, the Court's role to set a date for the election or to lay down timelines; those were matters for the President, the National Assembly and GECOM. By convention the Government was expected to act as a caretaker in the interim and to restrain the exercise of its legal authority. Costs were awarded against the Attorney General. In Mustapha v Attorney General and Chairman of GECOM [2019] CCJ 13 (AJ), the Court declared that the process used to appoint the GECOM Chairman was flawed and in breach of the Constitution and that the appointment was void, with costs to the appellant. As the Chairman had resigned, further orders were largely unnecessary, and the Court said that the appointment of a successor was a matter of the utmost urgency. On 11 July, in Sankar v Guyana Rice Development Board [2019] CCJ 11 (AJ), reported at [2019] GLR 225, the CCJ held that the Court of Appeal may enlarge time under Order 1, rule 8 of the Court of Appeal Rules to correct a clear miscarriage of justice. In doing so it must balance the interests of the dissatisfied litigant against those of the successful party.
From the Guyana Courts
In Sahadeo v Attorney General [2019] GLR 264 (26 July), the Court of Appeal considered section 219 of the Customs Act, which, on its wording, left the choice of penalty on conviction to the election of the Comptroller of Customs. Persaud JA, with whom Cummings-Edwards C (ag) and Gregory JA agreed, held that the section fell within the savings clause. Sentencing in individual cases, however, is the "quintessential" judicial function, and the provision breached the separation of powers. The offending words were severed so that the court fixes the penalty, leaving any modification to Parliament. The appeal was allowed. Gregory JA thought another reading was possible but agreed that the wording left the section open to an unconstitutional interpretation.
The accounts of Sankar and Sahadeo are taken from the reports at [2019] GLR 225 and 264. The accounts of the CCJ's 12 July decisions are taken from the written judgments at [2019] CCJ 13 (AJ) and [2019] CCJ 14 (AJ).
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
