The CCJ's Appellate Jurisdiction Rules 2019 replaced the 2017 Rules. The CCJ refused to stop the National Assembly sitting while the no-confidence appeals were pending. The High Court upheld a magistrate's committal of a Guyanese national for extradition to the United States.
The Deposit Insurance Act 2018 came into operation on 2 April under the commencement order gazetted in March. On 5 April two Bills to amend the National Accreditation Council Act 2004 were published (Bills Nos. 5 and 6). They became Acts in June.
On 16 April the President of the CCJ approved the Caribbean Court of Justice (Appellate Jurisdiction) Rules 2019, which amend and replace the 2017 Rules. They govern practice in appeals from Guyana and the Court's other appellate member states. The Rules cover the overriding objective, case management, leave to appeal, special leave, time, electronic filing and service of documents, and affidavits.
On 25 April the CCJ (Saunders PCCJ, Hayton and Rajnauth-Lee JJCCJ) dismissed an application by the former member whose vote carried the motion to restrain the National Assembly from sitting on 26 April until the no-confidence appeals were decided. Some reports said that applications by the other appellants were dismissed at the same time. As reported, the Court noted the Court of Appeal's decision that the motion was not validly passed. Unless and until the CCJ reversed that decision, the status of the Government and the National Assembly was unaffected by the vote, and it would be imprudent to take "the most unusual step" of restraining the Assembly from sitting. The application was dismissed under rule 9.7(c) of the new Rules, with costs to the Attorney General.
From the Guyana Courts
In the case reported as Williams v Commissioner of Police [2019] GLR 139 (4 April), Singh PJ refused a challenge under section 17 of the Fugitive Offenders Act to a magistrate's warrant of committal. The United States had requested the applicant's extradition to stand trial in Queens, New York. The affidavit of an eyewitness and medical evidence on the cause of death gave the magistrate more than sufficient evidence to commit for murder in the second degree under section 5 of the Act. The judge also criticised grounds in a fixed date application that ran to 42 substantive paragraphs of evidence. A ground, he said, is the legal principle relied on, not a restatement of the affidavit.
The account of the extradition case is taken from the report at [2019] GLR 139. The account of the CCJ's 25 April ruling is taken from press reports; no written ruling was located. Nothing here comments on the merits of the appeals then pending.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
