The Chief Justice (ag) ruled that the 21 December 2018 no-confidence motion was validly carried by 33 votes. The Natural Resource Fund Act 2019 and ten tax amendment Acts were gazetted.
The Natural Resource Fund Act 2019 (Act No. 12) was gazetted on 23 January, after the National Assembly passed it on 3 January. The Act creates the fund that will receive petroleum revenues. The Minister has overall management of the fund and the Bank of Guyana its operational management, with an Investment Committee, a Macroeconomic Committee and a Public Accountability and Oversight Committee. The Act fixes how much may be withdrawn each year: an "economically and fiscally sustainable amount", with separate provision for emergency financing. Withdrawals need parliamentary approval. The Act comes into operation on a date the Minister appoints by order.
On 21 January the 2019 budget measures were gazetted as Acts Nos. 1 to 10. They amend the Motor Vehicles and Road Traffic Act, the Property Tax Act, the Capital Gains Tax Act, the Tax Act, the Customs Act, the Intoxicating Liquor Licensing Act, the Value-Added Tax Act, the Income Tax Act, the Income Tax (In Aid of Industry) Act and the Corporation Tax Act. The Nurses and Midwives Act 2019 (Act No. 11) followed on 23 January.
From the Guyana Courts
On 31 January the Chief Justice (ag), George CJ (ag), decided two of the three challenges arising from the 21 December 2018 vote in the National Assembly. In Ram v Attorney General and Leader of the Opposition [2019] GLR 11, she declared that the Assembly had properly, validly and lawfully passed a motion of no confidence under article 106(6) of the Constitution, and that the Government was defeated. The Cabinet's resignation took effect immediately on the motion's success. Under article 106(7), however, the Government "shall remain in office" and must hold an election within three months, or within such longer period as the Assembly may set by a resolution supported by at least two-thirds of the elected members. Some of the declarations sought on timing could not be granted as framed. No order was made as to costs.
In Attorney General v Scotland, Jagdeo and Armon [2019] GLR 25, the Attorney General had asked the court to rule that 34 votes were needed. The Chief Justice (ag) held that the court had jurisdiction, since the Speaker had indicated that questions about his ruling should go to a court and nothing excluded the Attorney General from applying. She held that a no-confidence resolution carried in accordance with article 106(6) cannot be inconsistent with article 70(3). She also held that the majority required by article 106(6), being a majority of all the elected members, is at least 33 of 65. The motion carried 33 to 32, so the President and Ministers could not stay in office beyond the three months unless the Assembly enlarged that time.
The third case, Reid v Scotland, concerned the dual citizenship of the member whose vote carried the motion. The Chief Justice (ag) held that his election could have been challenged only by an election petition within the statutory time. She found that he held Canadian citizenship and so was not qualified to be elected, but that his vote stood. The Attorney General announced an appeal on the same day. The Court of Appeal's March decision on that appeal is reported at [2019] GLR 106.
The accounts of Ram and Attorney General v Scotland are taken from the reports at [2019] GLR 11 and 25. The account of the first-instance decision in Reid v Scotland is taken from press reports and has not been verified against a written judgment. The appeals were pending at the end of the month, and nothing here comments on their merits.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
