The CCJ held that the offence of appearing in public in clothing of the opposite sex for an improper purpose was unconstitutional and struck it from the statute book. Local government elections went ahead on 12 November after the High Court dismissed a challenge to the boundaries. Antigua and Barbuda voted in a referendum against making the CCJ its final court.
On 13 November, in McEwan v Attorney General [2018] CCJ 30 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 348, the CCJ (Saunders PCCJ delivering the judgment of the Court, with concurring judgments) allowed an appeal by four transgender appellants and the Society Against Sexual Orientation Discrimination. The appeal concerned section 153(1)(xlvii) of the Summary Jurisdiction (Offences) Act, Cap 8:02, which made it an offence for a man or a woman to appear in a public place in clothing of the opposite sex for an improper purpose. The Court held that the savings law clause did not protect the section, because post-independence amendments had cost it its character as existing law. The section violated the rights to equality and non-discrimination under articles 149 and 149D and to freedom of expression under article 146. It was also unconstitutionally vague and offended the rule of law. The Court struck the section from the Act. It held that SASOD had standing, and it found that the magistrate's sentencing remarks reflected stereotypical thinking. The appellants were awarded their costs in the CCJ and in the courts below.
Local government elections were held on 12 November for the 10 municipalities and 70 neighbourhood democratic councils. In Georgetown, the Elections Commission declared 21 seats for APNU, 7 for the PPP and 2 for the AFC, on a turnout of 28.3 per cent.
In a referendum in Antigua and Barbuda on 6 November, the proposal to replace the Privy Council with the CCJ failed. Preliminary figures showed 9,234 votes against and 8,509 in favour, well short of the required two-thirds majority.
From the Guyana Courts
On 9 November the High Court (Gino Persaud J) dismissed a judicial review challenge by a PPP-nominated GECOM commissioner, which sought to stop the elections in several neighbourhood council areas. The claim was that the Minister had not first issued an order fixing their boundaries. According to press reports, there was no evidence that the Chief Elections Officer had fixed or changed any boundaries. The boundaries had been established in 1990 and did not have to be published again. Costs of $150,000 and $100,000 were awarded to the Minister and the Chief Elections Officer.
The account of McEwan is taken from the report at [2018] GLR 348. The account of the boundaries decision is taken from press reports and has not been verified against a written judgment. The election results and referendum figures are taken from press reports.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
