The CCJ held that the consultation on the closure of the sugar estates, although imperfect, met the minimum legal standard. The Court of Appeal upheld paper committals in sexual offence cases. Parliament amended the local authorities' election laws, and polling day was fixed for 12 November.
The Local Authorities (Elections) (Amendment) Act 2018 (Act No. 10) was gazetted on 10 July. It amends the Municipal and District Councils Act, the Local Government Act, the Local Authorities (Elections) Act, the Local Democratic Organs Act and two earlier amending Acts. Mayors and deputy mayors now hold office for a calendar year. They are elected at a meeting called by 16 December, or within ten days after the results of a councillors' election are declared. By Order No. 24, made on 18 July, the Minister of Communities appointed 12 November 2018 as election day for the participating municipalities and neighbourhood democratic councils.
On 4 July Justice Adrian Saunders was sworn in as President of the CCJ in Montego Bay, Jamaica, succeeding Sir Dennis Byron.
On 31 July, in Basdeo v Guyana Sugar Corporation Ltd [2018] CCJ 24 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 274, the CCJ granted special leave but dismissed the appeal of sugar workers and their unions against the severance of workers at the Rose Hall and Enmore estates. On the evidence, a proper consultation process began with a stakeholders' meeting on 13 December 2016. The process was not perfect, and the Corporation could have engaged the unions more deeply. It nonetheless met the minimum requirements of the common law and of section 23(4) and (5) of the Trade Union Recognition Act. The Court did not decide the constitutional right-to-work claim, because it depended on the alleged failure to consult. It noted that CPR 56.03 allows a constitutional claim to be joined to one for an administrative order, and that joinder would have been prudent here. There was no order as to costs.
From the Guyana Courts
In DPP v Bacchus [2018] GLR 307 (24 July), the Court of Appeal (Cummings-Edwards Ch (ag), George CJ (ag) and Bulkan JA (ag)) allowed the Director's appeal and restored a committal for trial on a sexual offence against a child. The committal had been on paper under section 43 and the First Schedule of the Sexual Offences Act, without cross-examination of the witnesses. The High Court had quashed it as a breach of article 144. The Court of Appeal held that deferring cross-examination to the trial was rational and proportionate, because it spared complainants from being cross-examined twice. The accused had not shown that it was not reasonably justified. The Court also held that the challenge should not have been brought by prerogative writ, and that magistrates should not rule on constitutionality.
The accounts of Basdeo and Bacchus are taken from the reports at [2018] GLR 274 and 307. The account of the President's swearing-in is taken from press reports.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
