Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

Presidential Term Limits Upheld, the GECOM Chairman's Appointment Sustained and a Juvenile Justice Act

June 2018

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The CCJ held that the 2000 constitutional amendment imposing presidential term limits was validly passed without a referendum. The acting Chief Justice dismissed the challenge to the appointment of the GECOM Chairman. The Juvenile Justice Act 2018 raised the age of criminal responsibility to fourteen.

The Juvenile Justice Act 2018 (Act No. 8) was gazetted on 7 June. Section 4 presumes that no child under fourteen is capable of committing an offence. When a child is charged, the court must order an evaluation of the child's cognitive, emotional, psychological and social development. If the presumption is not rebutted, the child is referred to the Childcare and Protection Agency and the charge is withdrawn. A "juvenile" is a person aged fourteen to seventeen. The Act provides for diversion, pre-charge screening, a right to counsel, a presumption against detention before sentence, and sentencing in which custody is a last resort.

On 26 June the CCJ allowed the Attorney General's appeal in Attorney General v Richardson [2018] CCJ 17 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 198. The Constitution (Amendment) (No. 4) Act 2000 had amended article 90 to bar a person who has served two terms from election as President, and to add citizenship and residence qualifications. The High Court and a majority of the Court of Appeal held that this diluted the people's right under articles 1 and 9 to choose their President, so that the amendment needed a referendum. Byron PCCJ held that articles 1 and 9 do not regulate the qualifications of the President. Article 164 gives article 90 a lower level of entrenchment than articles 1 and 9. Qualifications such as age, citizenship, residence and term limits are normal in constitutions. The amendment was the product of a careful national process, and there was no consensus that term limits weaken democracy. Saunders and Wit JJCCJ gave separate judgments allowing the appeal, and Hayton, Rajnauth-Lee and Barrow JJCCJ concurred. Anderson JCCJ dissented. He would have dismissed the appeal and declared section 2 of the amending Act void, severing it from the rest of the Act. By a majority, the Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders below and declared that section 2 of the amending Act was a validly enacted amendment to article 90, with no order as to costs. The term limits stand.

On 20 June, in Thakur v Ori [2018] CCJ 16 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 185, the CCJ restored a declaration of prescriptive title to farmland. The family had farmed the land for more than the twelve-year period. The non-disclosures in the petition were not made to mislead the court but arose from ignorance of the law and inadequate legal representation. In the Court's words, "the land must go to the tiller".

On 27 June, in Nervais and Severin v The Queen [2018] CCJ 19 (AJ), the CCJ held the mandatory death penalty for murder in Barbados unconstitutional. It departed from the Privy Council's reading of the savings clause in Boyce and Joseph and ordered the appellants to be resentenced.

From the Guyana Courts

In Mustapha v Attorney General [2018] GLR 163 (8 June), George CJ (ag) dismissed a challenge to the President's appointment of a retired judge as Chairman of GECOM in October 2017, after he rejected three lists of six names from the Leader of the Opposition. Following Gaskin v Attorney General (2017), she held that article 161(2) required the President to appoint from the list only if the nominees had the qualities he had set out. Where they did not, he could act in his own deliberate judgment under article 111(1). The application was dismissed with $250,000 in costs. The Court of Appeal affirmed in October. In June 2019 the CCJ reversed the decision and overruled Gaskin to the extent of any inconsistency.

The account of Richardson is taken from the CCJ's judgment, [2018] CCJ 17 (AJ), and those of Thakur and Mustapha from the reports at [2018] GLR 185 and 163. The account of Nervais and Severin is taken from the CCJ's published summary.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.