Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The CCJ Restores the Lusignan Acquittals, Restates the Law on Stays of Execution and the Judicial Review Act Is Ordered into Force

May 2018

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The CCJ set aside a retrial order and restored the acquittals in Hyles and Williams, setting a strict test for prosecution appeals. In Rodrigues Architects it lifted a stay that had held up a judgment for years. The acting Chief Justice ordered the Minister of Legal Affairs to bring the Judicial Review Act 2010 into force by 31 July.

On 11 May the CCJ gave judgment in Hyles v Director of Public Prosecutions; Williams v Director of Public Prosecutions [2018] CCJ 12 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 105. The appellants had been acquitted by a jury in August 2013 on eleven counts of murder arising from the killings at Lusignan in January 2008. The DPP appealed under section 33B of the Court of Appeal Act, inserted in 2010, and in March 2016 the Court of Appeal ordered a retrial. Wit JCCJ, for the Court, rejected the argument that section 33B breaches the protection against double jeopardy in article 144(5), which itself contemplates appeals against acquittal. But because section 33B requires that the acquittal be "the result of" the error or irregularity, a prosecution appeal "should be measured against a rather strict standard". The test approaches one requiring a substantial degree of certainty that the jury would have convicted but for the error. There had been material irregularities, in jury selection and in the failure to investigate an allegation of improper communication with a juror, and one substantial misdirection. But the State's case rested on an uncorroborated former co-accused, and it could not be inferred that the jury would otherwise have convicted. The appeal was allowed and the acquittals restored.

On 4 May, in Rodrigues Architects Ltd v New Building Society Ltd [2018] CCJ 9 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 76, the CCJ granted special leave and discharged a stay of execution granted by a single Justice of Appeal in 2016 over a 2015 judgment for about $15.9 million in architectural fees. A stay is the exception, not the rule. The applicant must show a good prospect of success on appeal, and judges "must be alert to tactical appeals" by defendants seeking to delay payment. The company could collect the sum lodged with the Registrar, with interest, and enforce the balance, with $200,000 in costs.

On 16 May, in Ventose v Chief Electoral Officer [2018] CCJ 13 (AJ), the CCJ, as Barbados's final court, gave its reasons for an urgent decision. It had allowed the appeal of a Commonwealth citizen resident in Barbados and ordered that he be entered on the register of electors by noon on 14 May, ahead of the general election on 24 May. It declared unlawful and ultra vires the Electoral and Boundaries Commission's long-standing policy of registering Commonwealth citizens as electors only if they were permanent residents or held immigrant status.

From the Guyana Courts

In Nandlall v Minister of Legal Affairs [2018] GLR 138 (28 May), George CJ (ag) considered the Judicial Review Act 2010, passed in 2010 but never brought into operation. The Act was to be brought into force "with all convenient speed". The judge held that this phrase imposes no fixed time but requires action without unreasonable delay. Once the Civil Procedure Rules came into operation in February 2017, and the CCJ in Trueba confirmed that Part 56 was to apply to claims under the Act, the delay of more than a year was unreasonable and a breach of duty. The court may intervene where non-compliance would frustrate the policy of an Act. She made absolute the order nisi of mandamus and directed that the commencement order be signed by 31 July 2018, with $100,000 in costs. The Attorney General said he would appeal.

The accounts of Hyles, Rodrigues Architects and Nandlall are taken from the reports at [2018] GLR 105, 76 and 138. The account of Ventose is taken from the CCJ's reasons.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.