In Medical Council of Guyana v Trueba the CCJ held that judicial review claims are governed by the Civil Procedure Rules, even before the Judicial Review Act commences. The Insurance Act 2016 came into operation on 16 April. The Court of Appeal held that service in the Defence Force reserve does not attract a pension.
The Minister of Finance appointed 16 April 2018 as the day on which the Insurance Act 2016 came into operation (Order No. 6 of 2018, gazetted 9 April). Sections 59 to 62, paragraphs (f) to (j) of section 63, and section 64 were deferred for one year from that date. The Insurance Regulations 2018 (Regulations No. 1) were gazetted on 17 April.
On 6 April the CCJ gave its reasons in Medical Council of Guyana v Trueba [2018] CCJ 8 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 66. A doctor had applied without notice for orders nisi of certiorari and mandamus against the Council's refusal of full registration. The acting Chief Justice refused the application because the Medical Practitioners Act provides a right of appeal. The Court of Appeal remitted the claim. The CCJ allowed the Council's appeal and restored the High Court's dismissal. Barrow JCCJ explained that the parties had asked the Court to resolve "deep uncertainty" over whether the Civil Procedure Rules 2016 applied to judicial review, since it was still standard practice to use the old Crown Office procedure of orders nisi. The CPR apply to all civil proceedings, which include judicial review. Where the Rules are silent and no other enactment applies, rule 2.02(3) requires matters to be decided by analogy. Part 56 will govern claims under the Judicial Review Act when it commences, so it should apply by analogy now. Pending claims brought otherwise than under the CPR would have to be case managed, bearing in mind that a claim is not to be defeated only because the wrong form was used. The Court added observations on the duty of full and frank disclosure in without-notice applications, and commended all concerned for completing the case, from filing to final appeal, in six months.
The decision was relied on in May, when the High Court ordered the Minister of Legal Affairs to bring the Judicial Review Act into force.
From the Guyana Courts
In Rowley v Chief of Staff, Guyana Defence Force and Attorney General [2018] GLR 74 (10 April), the Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by a former member of the Defence Force reserve who claimed a pension. A pension for service in the reserve would be ultra vires the Defence (Pension and Gratuities) Regulations. Article 149B of the Constitution guarantees only a pension granted to a worker under a law or collective agreement. It does not create a free-standing right to one.
The accounts of Trueba and Rowley are taken from the reports at [2018] GLR 66 and 74.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
