Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The CCJ Upholds the 2% Minimum Corporation Tax, Leaves a $30 Million Acquisition Award Standing and Taxing Acts Are Read Purposively

March 2018

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

In Guyana Stores the CCJ held that the 2% minimum tax is a tax, not a forced loan, and that a taxpayer who bypasses the statutory objection procedure cannot use the Constitution instead. In Singh it dismissed an appeal over compulsorily acquired land but left a $30 million award undisturbed. The Court of Appeal rejected strict construction of taxing statutes.

On 5 March the CCJ dismissed the appeal in Guyana Stores Ltd v Attorney General [2018] CCJ 2 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 16. In May 2012 the Commissioner General had demanded about $3.8 billion in taxes. The company sought constitutional relief, arguing that the 2% minimum corporation tax under section 10A of the Corporation Tax Act was really a forced loan, so that collecting it would be a compulsory acquisition of property in breach of article 142. Barrow JCCJ, for the Court, rejected the analogy with IRC v Lilleyman (1964) 7 WIR 464. The State never repays the minimum tax; the taxpayer only receives a credit against future corporation tax, and "the obligation to repay is the essence of a loan". The minimum tax was therefore a tax within the exception in article 142(2)(a)(i). Section 10A was clear in taxing turnover, including in loss years. Whether the Revenue Authority had misapplied the section was a question of statutory interpretation, not a constitutional question. The company had a statutory route to dispute the assessments, which it had chosen not to use, and with the constitutional challenge dismissed there was "nothing for this Court to decide". Costs went to the respondents.

On 13 March, in Singh v Attorney General and National Industrial and Commercial Investments Ltd [2018] CCJ 3 (AJ), reported at [2018] GLR 50, the CCJ dismissed an appeal by the widow of an owner whose Georgetown property the State had compulsorily acquired in March 1983, after his death in 1980. The trial judge had had no jurisdiction to declare the High Court's earlier order fixing compensation a nullity, acting on the testimony of a partisan witness without the record. The claim had been brought in 1997, fourteen years after the acquisition order was published. Meanwhile the State and its lessees had done considerable work on the property, and third-party rights had accrued. It would be "a great injustice" to declare that the property had never vested in the State. The Court noted that long delay can extinguish a former owner's title under section 13 of the Title to Land (Prescription and Limitation) Act. But the State had been content to accept the Court of Appeal's decision, which had awarded $30 million, and the CCJ did not disturb it.

On 12 March the press reported that Justice Adrian Saunders of St Vincent and the Grenadines, a judge of the CCJ since its inception, would succeed Sir Dennis Byron as President in July.

From the Guyana Courts

In Grand Coastal Inn Inc v Guyana Revenue Authority [2018] GLR 26 (12 March), the Court of Appeal (Gregory, Persaud and Khan JJA) discharged orders of certiorari and prohibition by which the acting Chief Justice had declared VAT assessments against the hotel null and void, on the ground that they had not been made by the Commissioner General or under his direction. The Court rejected the view that taxing Acts must be strictly construed and strictly complied with. Article 142(2)(a)(i) implied no such rule. Although the appeal is reported under the hotel's name, it was brought by the Commissioner General. Endorsing AG v Carlton Bank [1899] 2 QB 158, it held that Parliament intends its taxing statutes "to be interpreted in a meaningful and purposeful way, giving effect to the objectives of the legislation".

The accounts of Guyana Stores and Singh are taken from the CCJ's judgments, [2018] CCJ 2 (AJ) and [2018] CCJ 3 (AJ), and that of Grand Coastal Inn from the report at [2018] GLR 26. The CCJ presidency item is taken from a press report.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.