Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The Court of Appeal Requires a Referendum for Term Limits, Upholds the Cross-Dressing Offence and the CCJ Allows One-Year Appellate Terms in Belize

February 2017

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

A majority of the Court of Appeal held that the 2000 presidential term-limits amendment needed a referendum. The court dismissed the challenge to the cross-dressing offence. The CCJ upheld Belize's constitutional amendment on one-year terms for appellate judges, but urged an end to the practice.

On 15 February, in Bar Association of Belize v Attorney General of Belize [2017] CCJ 4 (AJ), the CCJ dismissed a challenge to the Belize Constitution (Sixth Amendment) Act 2008. The amendment provided that a Justice of Appeal whose instrument of appointment did not specify a term would hold office for one year. The amendment itself was not unconstitutional. The Court nonetheless said that short, renewable terms weaken the guarantee of judicial independence. It recommended that Justices of Appeal be given the same security of tenure as Supreme Court judges, and that one-year appointments cease until that is done.

From the Guyana Courts

In Attorney General v Richardson [2017] GLR 44 (22 February), the Court of Appeal by a majority (Singh C (ag) writing for the majority, Cummings-Edwards CJ (ag) dissenting) agreed with the High Court. The Constitution (Amendment) (No. 4) Act 2000 imposed two-term limits and new citizenship and residence qualifications for the presidency. In the majority's view, those changes to article 90 diluted the democratic sovereignty protected by articles 1 and 9, so a referendum under article 164(2)(a) was required. The dissent held that articles 1 and 9 were untouched and that a two-thirds majority sufficed. The CCJ allowed the further appeal in June 2018.

In McEwan v Attorney General [2017] GLR 92 (27 February), the Court of Appeal held that the appellants' guilty pleas did not bar their constitutional challenge. It agreed with the High Court, however, that section 153(1)(xlvii) of the Summary Jurisdiction (Offences) Act targeted dressing in clothing of the opposite sex for an improper purpose and was not discriminatory. It set aside the High Court's finding of a breach of article 139(3) and its award of damages, which rested on conflicting affidavits. The appeal was dismissed. The CCJ reversed in November 2018.

In Guyana Stores Ltd v Attorney General [2017] GLR 15 (20 February), the Court of Appeal gave its reasons for its unanimous decision of 21 December 2016 that the relief the company sought would not be granted. It held that a demand for taxes under the taxing statutes did not engage the constitutional protection against deprivation of property. Constitutional relief should not be clogged with what is really a tax dispute, and the company had its remedy under the Tax Act.

The accounts of Richardson, McEwan and Guyana Stores are taken from the reports at [2017] GLR 44, 92 and 15. The account of the Belize appeal is taken from the CCJ's judgment.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.