Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The CCJ on Homosexual Entry Bans in CARICOM, Magistrates' Appeal Timelines and a Legitimate Expectation Claim to State Land

June 2016

Published 17 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The CCJ dismissed a challenge to the immigration laws of Belize and Trinidad and Tobago but warned against keeping conflicting laws on the books. It held that a late clerk's notice does not invalidate a magistrate's appeal record. It refused special leave in a State land claim.

On 10 June, in Tomlinson v Belize; Tomlinson v Trinidad and Tobago [2016] CCJ 1 (OJ), the CCJ in its original jurisdiction dismissed a Jamaican attorney's claims. He had argued that provisions of their immigration laws listing homosexuals among prohibited immigrants prejudiced his Community right of hassle-free entry recognised in Myrie. The Court read the Belize provision as aimed only at those who profit from sexual services. In Trinidad and Tobago, State practice, and the State's duty under the Revised Treaty to admit homosexual nationals of other Member States, meant that he had not shown he had been or would be prejudiced. His claims against both States therefore failed. It added that its ruling was not to be taken as condoning the indefinite retention of national laws that appear to conflict with Community obligations. Each party bore its own costs, because the case raised novel questions of Community law.

On 6 June, in Ramlall v Attorney General [2016] CCJ 11 (AJ), reported at [2016] GLR 85, the CCJ refused special leave to a farmer who claimed a legitimate expectation of a lease of 91 acres of State land in Corentyne. He had been let into occupation in 1993 and removed in 1998. The application was out of time with no extension sought, and on the merits disclosed no arguable case.

On 10 June, in Singh v Harrychan [2016] CCJ 12 (AJ), reported at [2016] GLR 89, the CCJ allowed a prosecution appeal. It interpreted section 8(2) of the Summary Jurisdiction (Appeals) Act, which governs the preparation of the record in appeals from magistrates. The timeline must be strictly complied with, and non-compliance may attract administrative sanctions, but it does not invalidate a clerk's notice issued out of time. Service on the intended appellant's lawyer on record was sufficient.

From the Guyana Courts

In Readymix Concrete Ltd v Khaiyoum [2016] GLR 101 (Full Court, June), the court set aside an order allowing a receiver to make two companies pay a $26 million judgment debt owed by a deceased shareholder. On his death his shares vested in his executors or administrators, and the companies were separate legal persons not liable for his debt.

The account of Readymix is taken from the report at [2016] GLR 101, which gives the hearing dates, the last of them 27 June. The CCJ accounts are taken from the CCJ's judgments and the reports at [2016] GLR 85 and 89.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.