The President prorogued the Tenth Parliament. The High Court held that a rule barring cross-examination of the makers of witness statements at sexual offence inquiries was unconstitutional, a ruling the Court of Appeal reversed in 2018, and the CCJ refused a doctor special leave in a disciplinary dispute.
Proclamation No. 1 of 2014, gazetted on 10 November, prorogued the Tenth Parliament under article 70(1) of the Constitution with effect from 10 November 2014. According to press reports, the prorogation came as the opposition prepared a no-confidence motion against the Government.
On 28 November the CCJ ([2014] CCJ 18 (AJ)) refused special leave to a medical practitioner whose erasure from the register had been quashed by the High Court on procedural grounds. Res judicata requires a final decision on the merits, and a decision quashed for procedural reasons is not one, so there was no res judicata.
From the Guyana Courts
On 14 November the acting Chief Justice held that article 144(1) of the Constitution does not confer a right to a preliminary inquiry, so section 43 of the Sexual Offences Act 2010 was not unconstitutional. However, paragraph 5 of the First Schedule to the Act was inconsistent with article 144(2)(d) and (e) in so far as it disallowed cross-examination of the makers of prosecution witness statements. The magistrate’s committal of the applicant was quashed. On 24 July 2018 the Court of Appeal reversed this decision, holding that deferring cross-examination to the trial in the High Court did not make the trial unfair and was a proportionate way of sparing complainants from being cross-examined twice. It restored the committal.
The account of the prorogation’s political context is taken from press reports and has not been verified. The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2014] GLR 343, [2018] GLR 306 and [2014] GLR 350 and the CCJ's judgment.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
