The High Court held that a private owner can have only a right of user over a foreshore and awarded mesne profits against the State for a ferry ramp at Vreed-en-Hoop. It refused to set aside a transport held by innocent purchasers after a fraudulent declaration of title, and quashed tax assessments made without disclosing the records relied on.
From the Guyana Courts
On 10 September, in Chichester v Baker, the acting Chief Justice held that where transport was passed on a declaration of title made by a Commissioner of Title and then passed on twice, the transport in the hands of the third holder could be declared void against him only if he was a party or privy to the fraud of the first. The first holder had entered no defence, and his fraud was accepted, but the later holders were innocent purchasers for value. The court declined to set aside the irregularly obtained declaration and awarded the claimants damages for fraud against the first holder only, to be assessed on the property’s market value at the time of the first sale, refusing all other remedies.
On 19 September, in Rayman v Attorney General, the High Court considered a claim by the owner of an undivided one-sixth share in Plantation Vreed-en-Hoop over a ramp built on the foreshore beside the ferry stelling and used by speedboat operators who paid a landing fee. It held that section 4(7) of the Civil Law of Guyana Act recognises only a private right of user over a foreshore, not ownership, and that the area was not a sea defence district, so the canal had not vested in the State under the Sea Defence Act. The plaintiff was entitled to mesne profits for the Transport and Harbours Department’s trespass, limited to the three years before the action was filed in October 2007. The court assessed them at $9,636,000 with interest, and costs of $150,000, against the Attorney General only, since the Department is not a legal entity.
On 19 September, in Re Saeed Alladin, the court quashed additional income tax assessments for 2008 to 2011 because the Assistant Commissioner, who had penalised the taxpayer for lacking proper records and accounts, refused his request for copies of the records on which the findings were based. The assessments failed the requirements of fairness and natural justice.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2014] GLR 282, 305 and 299.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
