The CCJ upheld two convictions but required credit for time spent on remand. The High Court held that the disciplinary law of the Defence Force was largely shielded from the fundamental rights provisions, and quashed the Georgetown Public Hospital board’s termination of an employee.
On 9 June the CCJ ([2014] CCJ 11 (AJ)) dismissed appeals against convictions for breaking and entering and larceny and affirmed the four-year sentences, but ordered that each appellant be credited with the four days spent on remand.
From the Guyana Courts
On 13 June the acting Chief Justice dismissed a constitutional motion by a member of the Guyana Defence Force about his treatment under military discipline. Under article 152(3) of the Constitution, nothing done under the disciplinary law of a disciplined force can be held inconsistent with the fundamental rights provisions other than articles 138, 140 and 141. On the evidence, the treatment fell short of being inhuman or degrading, let alone torture, under article 141.
On 16 June, in Re Mohamed Karimullah, the court held that the employment and termination of staff of the Georgetown Public Hospital Corporation was a matter for the Executive Director, not the board. The board’s termination of the applicant was ultra vires the Georgetown Public Hospital Order 1999 and was quashed.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2014] GLR 182, 192 and 204 and the CCJ's judgment.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
