Sitting in Guyana, the CCJ granted special leave in a dispute over a two-acre parcel where the courts below had made conflicting findings of fact, and the Speaker appealed the budget-cuts ruling.
On 18 February the CCJ, sitting in Guyana, granted special leave to appeal in Ramlagan v Singh [2014] CCJ 5 (AJ), a dispute over a two-acre parcel out of a twelve-acre tract. It gave its reasons on 21 March. Although the Court is ordinarily reluctant to disturb concurrent findings of fact, the conflicting findings arising from the Court of Appeal’s decision and the unsettled position on the disputed land were exceptional circumstances. Leave to appeal as a poor person was refused because there was no evidence of net worth. When the appeal itself was decided in June 2015, the CCJ held that the respondent’s twelve years of adverse possession had extinguished the paper title.
On the same day the CCJ granted special leave to appeal to two men convicted by a magistrate of breaking and entering and larceny, finding it arguable that their defence had not been properly put at trial. Citing its overriding objective of dealing with cases fairly and expeditiously, it dispensed with a formal record of appeal and fixed the hearing for 10 April.
The Speaker of the National Assembly filed an appeal on 25 February against the January ruling in the budget-cuts case. In his directions on the 2014 estimates, he said the Assembly would make every reasonable effort to respect the High Court’s decision, without prejudice to the appeal.
The account of Ramlagan v Singh is taken from the report at [2014] GLR 67 and the CCJ's judgments. The account of the Speaker’s appeal is taken from the Speaker’s published ruling and press reports and has not been verified against court records.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
