The High Court held that the National Assembly could approve or reject the Finance Minister’s estimates but not cut them, a ruling later reversed. The CCJ struck down Belize legislation, and the High Court allowed citizens to ask whether NICIL’s money belonged in the Consolidated Fund.
On 24 January, in Attorney General of Belize v Zuniga [2014] CCJ 2 (AJ), the CCJ considered two 2010 Acts amending Belize’s Supreme Court of Judicature Act, the first of which added a new section 106A and which, among other things, made it an offence to disobey an anti-arbitration injunction. It held the amendment inconsistent with the Constitution of Belize and invalidated it in its entirety, dismissing the State’s appeal.
From the Guyana Courts
On 29 January, in Attorney General v Trotman, Granger and Singh, the acting Chief Justice declared that the National Assembly, through the Committee of Supply, had acted unconstitutionally in reducing the Finance Minister’s estimates of expenditure for 2012. Under article 218 the Assembly may approve or withhold approval of the estimates, but it has no power to amend them by reduction or increase, and its Standing Orders cannot confer one. The court added that it would not generally interfere in the Assembly’s internal operations, but could declare its conduct unconstitutional. According to press reports, in early 2016 the Court of Appeal reversed the ruling on the Speaker’s appeal, holding that the Assembly may amend the estimates, including by reducing them, by majority vote.
On 2 January, in Trotman v Attorney General, the court rejected a challenge to the procedure used by the claimants and held that, as citizens, they could properly raise the constitutional question whether money held by the National Industrial and Commercial Investments Ltd (NICIL) was public money that should be paid into the Consolidated Fund. It reserved its ruling on standing until it had considered the merits.
The accounts of the High Court decisions are taken from the reports at [2014] GLR 25 and 1. The account of the later appeal in the budget case is taken from press reports and has not been verified against a written judgment.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
