Orders exempting renewed medium-scale permits from rental fees were gazetted. The High Court quashed a Public Service Commission finding as irrational and set aside a firearm licence revocation based on a report its maker had retracted.
The Gazette of 9 November listed the Rental Fees of Renewed Prospecting Medium Scale (Exemption) Order 2013 (Order No. 21 of 2013), together with thirteen orders transferring property of the National Industrial and Commercial Investments Ltd connected with Linmine. The Gazette of 30 November published the Rental Fees for Renewed Mining Permits Medium Scale (Exemption) Order 2013 (Order No. 36 of 2013), made under section 134 of the Mining Act 1989, which exempted a named permit holder from rental fees on his renewed medium-scale mining permit for five years from the date of grant.
From the Guyana Courts
On 8 November the acting Chief Justice quashed a Public Service Commission finding against a public officer. The challenge was for irrationality, so the Commission had to show that the evidence before it was capable of supporting its finding. The only invoice in evidence was in the officer’s own name, and the content of the witnesses’ evidence was largely unknown. The order of certiorari was made absolute, with costs of $40,000.
On 22 November the court held irrational the revocation of a firearm licence that rested on a relative’s report, which he had later retracted. A suspicion that the retraction was untrue, even if reasonable, could not without further investigation be turned into a positive finding. The orders of certiorari and mandamus were made absolute.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2013] GLR 461 and 464. Order No. 36 was read in the Gazette; only the titles of the 9 November orders were read.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
