The High Court awarded damages for an unconstitutional search and a three-day detention, and twice held that the Public Service Commission had not followed its own disciplinary rules.
From the Guyana Courts
In August the acting Chief Justice awarded $325,000, with interest and costs of $30,000, to a man who had been searched near a gas station and then held for three days on information that he was involved in an armed robbery. The search without consent breached article 143, and $25,000 was awarded for it. The police could not show reasonable grounds for the arrest, so the detention breached article 139(1), and $300,000 was awarded for that.
On 2 August the court held that the Public Service Commission could not delegate its disciplinary function to an investigative body it had approved. Under Rule 66 of its Rules it may delegate only to a Permanent Secretary or Head of Department, and only with the Prime Minister’s approval. The Commission had also found the officer guilty before calling on him to answer the charges, relying on the Ministry’s request for his dismissal.
On 23 August the court held unlawful the dismissal of a public officer for failing to comply with the Public Service rules, because no departmental charge had been brought or served under Rule 66(1)(b). The Commission could not find her guilty of an offence with which she had never been charged, and she was awarded damages against the State for five months’ loss of earnings, measured as the difference between her former salary and what she earned after her dismissal, with interest, together with her accrued superannuation benefits and costs of $25,000.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2013] GLR 348, 356 and 382.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
