Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

Belize’s Unlegislated Tax Deal Unenforceable, Two Guyanese Appeals Revived by Special Leave and No Expectation of a Renewed GECOM Contract

July 2013

Published 17 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The CCJ refused to enforce an arbitral award founded on an unlegislated tax regime in Belize and used special leave to correct two Court of Appeal errors. The High Court held there is no public law right to the renewal of an employment contract.

On 26 July, in BCB Holdings Ltd v Attorney General of Belize [2013] CCJ 5 (AJ), the CCJ dismissed the banks’ appeal and refused to enforce a London arbitral award founded on a settlement deed that gave them a special tax regime never approved by the Belize legislature. Enforcing it would be contrary to public policy. The Court stressed its respect for international commercial arbitration, and made no order as to costs.

On 22 July, in Mahamad v S & R Abdulla Cane Farming Inc [2013] CCJ 8 (AJ), the CCJ granted special leave and set aside orders of the Court of Appeal of 30 January 2013. Roy JA had been within his jurisdiction in extending time to appeal, because the rules allowed a month’s grace, so his orders were restored.

On 23 July, in Andrews v Moore [2013] CCJ 7 (AJ), the CCJ extended time, granted special leave and set aside a Court of Appeal order of 22 February 2013 whose dismissal of the appeal amounted to a potential miscarriage of justice and an egregious error of law. It restored the High Court’s order of 2007 and remitted the appeal to the Court of Appeal to be heard on the merits.

From the Guyana Courts

On 15 July, in Re Boodhoo, the acting Chief Justice held that, however good an employee’s past performance, no presumptive right to the renewal of a contract of employment with the Guyana Elections Commission can arise in public law. A legitimate expectation could not override the Commission’s right to contract or not to contract, and the application for prerogative orders was refused.

The account of Re Boodhoo is taken from the report at [2013] GLR 298. The accounts of the CCJ decisions are taken from the CCJ's judgments.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.