Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

A Prescriptive Claim Fails at the CCJ, a Minister Cannot Block Mining Permit Renewals and an Unreliable Handwriting Expert

May 2013

Published 17 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The CCJ dismissed a claim to land by prescription. The High Court held that the Minister could not instruct the mining commission to refuse renewals, and rejected a forgery claim that rested on an unreliable handwriting expert.

On 15 May, in Ali v Choong [2013] CCJ 3 (AJ), the CCJ dismissed an appeal by an occupier who claimed title by prescription to land at Springlands. He had first occupied the house under a bare licence, he could not prove that the licence had been revoked, and he admitted that until 2000 he did not believe he owned it. Like the Court of Appeal, the CCJ found that he had failed to prove title or possession. Costs were awarded to the respondents.

From the Guyana Courts

On 17 May, in Re Vieira, the acting Chief Justice held that the Minister had no legal authority to instruct the Guyana Geology and Mines Commission not to renew a miner’s permits. The Commission’s power of renewal under section 63 of the Mining Act was not subject to ministerial approval, and acting on such an instruction would be an unlawful surrender of its discretion. The orders of certiorari and mandamus were made absolute, and the Commissioner was directed to consider at once whether cease work orders should issue to everyone mining on the lands covered by the permits. Costs of $150,000 were ordered against the respondents jointly and severally.

On 10 May, in Williams v John, the court dismissed a claim that an affidavit of donor was a forgery. The administrator had accepted the document for years and raised forgery only after obtaining a handwriting examiner’s report, and the court found the examiner’s opinion unreliable.

The accounts of the Guyana decisions are taken from the reports at [2013] GLR 190 and 164. The account of Ali v Choong is taken from the CCJ's judgment.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.