The High Court declared unconstitutional the National Assembly’s bar on the Minister of Home Affairs, upheld a magistrate’s order for disclosure of prosecution statements, and awarded damages for an arrest made without reasonable suspicion.
From the Guyana Courts
On 1 March, in Attorney General v Granger and Trotman (No. 2), the acting Chief Justice declared that, in so far as the National Assembly had prohibited the Minister of Home Affairs from speaking in the Assembly and from presenting any bill, motion or petition for debate, the Speaker, as the Assembly’s representative, had acted unlawfully and unconstitutionally. The court, and not the Assembly, has the final word on questions of law about members’ rights and privileges, but its orders in such a case are declaratory, not coercive. According to press reports, the Speaker had already lifted the restriction on 22 February, and no appeal against the declaration has been traced.
On 8 March the court declined to interfere with a magistrate’s order that the prosecution disclose its witness statements to an accused charged with possession of illegal petroleum. The offence, which carried a fine of up to three million dollars and three years’ imprisonment, was not petty, and nothing made disclosure impracticable or unfair to the prosecution. Had the magistrate refused, the court said, the accused would have had arguable grounds for mandamus. The prosecuting agency’s orders nisi of certiorari and prohibition were discharged, with costs of $20,000.
On 22 March, in Simon v Attorney General, the court held that the plaintiff’s arrest, made solely because he had visited a detained acquaintance at CID Headquarters, was without reasonable suspicion and breached article 139(1). His overnight detention in crowded and insanitary lock-ups aggravated the breach. He was awarded $250,000, with costs of $40,000. The State was not responsible for his later detention by United States immigration authorities.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2013] GLR 95, 103 and 137. The lifting of the restriction by the Speaker is taken from press reports and has not been verified against the parliamentary record.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
