The CCJ granted special leave and extended time for an appeal that the Court of Appeal had refused to hear. The High Court held that the Minister could not instruct the GGMC to refuse renewal fees for prospecting permits, and that orders nisi cannot be appealed as final orders.
On 29 October, in [2012] CCJ 8 (AJ), an application from Guyana, the CCJ set aside the Court of Appeal’s refusal on 12 December 2011 to extend time for an appeal, and extended the time to 9 November 2012. Despite the inordinate delay, the Court of Appeal should have weighed the possible merits of the appeal in deciding whether to extend time. There appeared to be an error of $700,000 in the sum for which judgment had been entered, and the transaction, involving a confiscated vehicle used without proper documents, might be tainted with illegality, a point a court must take of its own motion. The respondent was ordered to pay the costs of the application.
From the Guyana Courts
On 5 October, in Re Guyana Gold and Diamond Miners Association, the acting Chief Justice quashed the Guyana Geology and Mines Commission’s refusal to accept the prescribed fees for renewing prospecting permits. Nothing in section 59 of the Mining Act made the Commission’s discretion subject to the Minister’s direction, so the Minister’s instruction was without legal effect, and refusing the fees was an unlawful dereliction of statutory duty. An application by neighbouring Amerindian villages to extend their village area over the permit lands was not a rational basis for refusing to consider renewal, although a permit holder has no absolute right to renewal.
On 2 October the court held that orders nisi are not final orders and cannot be appealed to the Court of Appeal. In a taxpayer’s challenge to additional income tax assessments, the six-week period for appealing had in any event expired long before the orders nisi of 26 April were made absolute on 3 July.
The account of the CCJ application is taken from the CCJ’s judgment. The accounts of the Guyana decisions are taken from the reports at [2012] GLR 366 and 359.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
