Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

An Appeal as of Right From a Refused Order Nisi, the Bel Air Gardens Open Space and a Share of Matrimonial Property

June 2012

Published 17 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The CCJ held that refusing an ex parte motion for an order nisi of certiorari is a final order, so an appeal lies as of right to the Court of Appeal. The High Court struck out a developer’s constitutional motion in the Bel Air Gardens dispute and divided matrimonial property.

On 11 June, in [2012] CCJ 2 (AJ), an appeal brought by two trustees of the Guyana Cricket Board who had challenged the Minister’s decision to install an interim management committee to run cricket, the CCJ held that an order refusing an originating ex parte motion for an order nisi of certiorari is a final order within section 6(2) of the Court of Appeal Act. Seeking such a public law remedy against an alleged abuse of public power is so significant under the Constitution that an appeal lies as of right to the Court of Appeal. The bar in section 6(5)(d) covers only ex parte applications made in existing inter partes proceedings, and only those applications may be renewed before the Full Court under Order 46, rule 16. The Full Court therefore had no jurisdiction to hear their renewed application, and the Court of Appeal was right, though for the wrong reason, to hold that it could not hear an appeal from the Full Court. The CCJ dismissed the appeal but, exercising the Court of Appeal’s powers, extended the time to appeal against the original refusal of 29 December 2011.

From the Guyana Courts

On 6 June, in Property Holdings Inc v Attorney General, the acting Chief Justice struck out as misconceived a developer’s constitutional motion. In judicial review proceedings, proprietors of Bel Air Gardens had challenged the Central Housing and Planning Authority’s permission to change the use of the estate’s open space from recreation to housing. The developer complained that it had been denied a fair hearing when its application to be joined was not heard. The court held that the question in the review was simply whether the Authority had acted within its statutory power. Article 144(8) and (9) apply only where proceedings determine civil rights and obligations, and even a refusal of joinder could not have grounded a claim for constitutional redress. Costs of $75,000 were awarded to the proprietors who applied to strike out.

On 1 June the court decided a wife’s application under the Married Persons Property Act for a share of matrimonial property. It found that soon after the marriage she had chosen to use the matrimonial assets to improve her own education and finances, reducing her contribution to her husband’s business ventures, two of which failed. On the basis that she would not have to give up the assets she had put aside for herself, she was awarded $1.5 million as her share of the matrimonial assets held by her husband. Each party bore their own costs.

The account of the CCJ appeal is taken from the report at [2012] GLR 181. The accounts of the Guyana decisions are taken from the reports at [2012] GLR 164 and 160.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.