The High Court held that prerogative proceedings could not be brought against the President over a broadcasting licence suspension, that the Revenue Authority could seize a vehicle but could not take it for its own use without forfeiture proceedings, and that a manufacturer had been wrongly taxed as a commercial company.
From the Guyana Courts
On 2 May the acting Chief Justice discharged an order nisi of certiorari against the Advisory Committee on Broadcasting, which had found that a television station breached its licence conditions and recommended a suspension. The President had kept responsibility for public broadcasting and had not assigned it to the Minister under article 107 of the Constitution, and the suspension had been imposed by the President, not the Committee. Apart from the applicants’ delay, no prerogative writ proceedings could be brought against the President as Head of State. Even if two Committee members had not been qualified for appointment, their acts and decisions were not invalid for that reason: they had served since 2001 without challenge, and there was no evidence that any member knew of the prescribed qualifications or of any lack of them. Because the station’s owners admitted the breaches, the Committee’s failure to give reasons for its findings was not unfair. There was no order as to costs.
On 11 May the acting Chief Justice held that the Commissioner-General had lawfully seized and detained a motor vehicle under the Customs Act, even if its owner had bought it in good faith. But the Commissioner-General could not dispose of it in favour of the Revenue Authority without first taking forfeiture and condemnation proceedings under section 225(2), and by doing so he infringed the owner’s right to his property. The words 'whereupon proceedings shall be taken' were directory as to time but mandatory in that the proceedings must be brought. The court declared void the vehicle’s registration in the Revenue Authority’s name but made no order for compensation, since it could not tell whether forfeiture proceedings would succeed.
On 17 May, in Re Bermudez Biscuit Co Ltd, the court quashed corporation tax assessments for 1997 to 2000. Whether a company is a 'commercial company' does not depend on its nationality or registration, but on the definition in section 2 of the Corporation Tax Act: a company at least 75% of whose gross income comes from trading in goods it does not manufacture. The company, an external company registered in Trinidad and Tobago, earned more than 25% of its gross income from products it made itself. The Commissioner-General had misapplied section 10A, and the orders nisi of certiorari and prohibition against him were made absolute. Those against the Revenue Authority were discharged, because the Commissioner-General, not the Authority, makes tax assessments.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2012] GLR 1, 121 and 126. The date of the broadcasting decision is taken from press reports; the law report dates it 1 January 2012, evidently in error.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
