The Court of Appeal substituted manslaughter for murder where provocation had not been left to the jury, the High Court confirmed its power to quash a committal unsupported by evidence, and it refused to find possession for prescription by an occupier who never intended to exclude the Government.
From the Guyana Courts
On 12 May the Court of Appeal allowed an appeal against a conviction for murder. A trial judge must leave to the jury every issue that properly arises on the evidence, whether or not the defence raises it. The appellant’s statement described abuse and a violent attack by the deceased, so provocation should have been left to the jury, and the judge had also misdirected it on intention, which is subjective. Failing to record a finding that a statement was voluntary, and disclosing the voir dire ruling to the jury, were irregularities that caused no injustice. A conviction for manslaughter was substituted, with a sentence of fifteen years.
On 31 May the acting Chief Justice held that the High Court may, on judicial review, quash a magistrate’s committal for trial on an indictable offence if there was no or insufficient evidence to support it. In the case before him the order nisi was discharged.
On 25 May the court dismissed a claim to set aside a declaration of title to land, finding no fraud by the defendants. Even if the plaintiff had occupied the land alone since 1964, he had never intended to exclude the Government, so his occupation lacked the intention to possess needed for prescription.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2010] GLR 111, 126 and 122.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
