Parliament gave the Director of Public Prosecutions a right of appeal against acquittals and sentences, the CCJ declared Guyana in breach of the Revised Treaty for its slow compliance in the cement tariff case and ordered heirs to convey land sold by their father, and the Court of Appeal set aside a mandamus against the Medical Council.
The Court of Appeal (Amendment) Act 2010 (Act No. 4), passed on 18 March, inserts a new Part IIIA in the Court of Appeal Act giving the Director of Public Prosecutions a right to appeal to the Court of Appeal against an acquittal on indictment that results from the judge upholding a no-case submission or withdrawing the case from the jury, upholding a submission of a defect in the depositions, committal or indictment, excluding material prosecution evidence, substantially misdirecting the jury, or a material irregularity in the trial. The Director may also appeal against a sentence on indictment that the court had no power to pass, or that is manifestly inadequate or wrong in principle. Notice of intention to appeal must be given before the trial judge discharges the accused.
On 29 March, in Trinidad Cement Ltd and TCL Guyana Inc v Guyana [2010] CCJ 1 (OJ), the CCJ declared that Guyana had breached article 215 of the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas by failing to comply promptly with its order of 20 August 2009 to reinstate the common external tariff on cement from outside CARICOM. It dismissed the claims against the Attorney General for an order to show cause and a declaration of contempt, refused to entertain an oral claim that Guyana was in contempt, and observed that the CCJ Act contains no express provision for enforcing the Court’s original jurisdiction orders through the domestic courts. Guyana was ordered to pay half the applicants’ taxed costs.
On 31 March, in [2010] CCJ 2 (AJ), the CCJ allowed an appeal in a dispute arising from a 1980 sale of land at Plantation Ruimzight, West Coast Demerara. The seller had died and the land passed to his children without consideration. Fraud in the proviso to section 23 of the Deeds Registry Act includes an owner’s deliberate breach of a contract of sale to transfer to someone who knows of it and assists in the breach, and the twelve-month limitation applies to every kind of fraud. But in Roman-Dutch law, which does not know equitable interests, specific performance can be had against a volunteer. Despite nine years’ delay, most of it caused by deceit, the heirs were ordered to convey the land within eight weeks. The CCJ thereby reversed the majority decision of the Court of Appeal.
From the Guyana Courts
Also on 31 March the Court of Appeal allowed an appeal by the Medical Council of Guyana against an order of mandamus requiring it to register a doctor as a medical practitioner. The Council has a discretion to grant or refuse registration on lawful, just and fair grounds. The trial judge had substituted his own view of the merits for the Council’s, and should have declined to hear the motion at all, because section 19 of the Medical Practitioners Act gives a statutory appeal to a judge in chambers.
The account of the Act is taken from its text as published by the Parliament of Guyana. The accounts of the CCJ decisions are taken from the CCJ’s judgments and the reports at [2010] GLR 56 and 73, and that of the Medical Council appeal from the report at [2010] GLR 67.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
