Parliament again postponed local government elections; the Full Court freed a man held for extradition to the United States; the acting Chief Justice held that years of delay over broadcasting licence applications breached freedom of expression; and the CCJ dismissed two stale public service claims.
The Local Authorities (Elections) (Amendment) Act 2008 (Act No. 23), passed on 29 December and deemed in force from 1 November 2008, amends section 36A(1) of the Local Authorities (Elections) Act by substituting “twelve years” for “eleven years”, postponing the elections of councillors of local democratic organs, which are now to be held on or before a date in December 2009; the Minister may still authorise an earlier election for a particular local democratic organ.
On 16 December, in [2008] CCJ 10 (AJ), the CCJ dismissed an appeal by a public servant dismissed in 1981 without a hearing, affirming the Court of Appeal. All the issues in his second action could and should have been raised in his first, so the second was an abuse of process. In [2008] CCJ 11 (AJ), decided the same day, the CCJ dismissed an appeal by a senior police officer whose services were ended in the public interest in 1984. His delay of over sixteen years from dismissal, and over thirteen from his petition to the President, was inordinate, and stale constitutional claims without a cogent explanation can be an abuse of the court’s jurisdiction.
From the Guyana Courts
On 10 December the Full Court (the acting Chief Justice and Ramlal J) made absolute orders of certiorari, prohibition and habeas corpus for a man whose extradition to the United States on drug charges the Minister of Home Affairs had approved. The 1931 United Kingdom–United States treaty, which applies to Guyana, speaks only to the rule of specialty and contains no undertaking against re-extradition to a third country, so the Commissioner of Police and the Director of Prisons had no authority to hold him for extradition, and his detention breached section 8(3)(b) of the Fugitive Offenders Act 1988 and was unlawful and unconstitutional. On 18 December a Justice of Appeal in chambers held, in related proceedings, that extradition is part of the criminal process, so the Court of Appeal had no jurisdiction to hear the Attorney General’s appeal. In October 2009 Parliament amended section 8 to allow extradition in such cases where the Minister considers it in the interest of justice (see October 2009).
On 12 December the acting Chief Justice held that the State’s excessive delay in dealing with two Linden residents’ applications, pending since 2001, for licences to operate a radio and television network in Region 10 infringed their freedom of expression under article 146, by hindering their freedom as residents to receive ideas and information. The need to modernise broadcasting legislation and build political consensus was no excuse for such tardiness, and any refusal must fall within article 146(2). The Government was ordered to consider the applications under the existing law once the applicants supplied sufficient information. The claim of discrimination by place of origin failed, as did the claim against the Elections Commission, which had no control over broadcasting licences; each party bore its own costs. In October 2009 the Court of Appeal reached a similar conclusion on a radio licence application (see October 2009).
The accounts of the Acts are taken from their texts as published by the Parliament of Guyana. The accounts of the CCJ decisions are taken from the CCJ’s judgments and the reports at [2008] GLR 339 and 353, and those of the High Court and Court of Appeal decisions from the reports at [2008] GLR 302, 357 and 315.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
