Parliament passed laws on drink-driving evidence, police supervision of convicts, piracy and visiting forces; the CCJ upheld a company’s prescriptive title, reaffirmed that Guyana recognises no equitable interests in land and heard Trinidad Cement’s first claim; and the Court of Appeal ruled on consumption tax on locally made spirits.
On 3 July Parliament passed the Hijacking and Piracy Act 2008 (Act No. 8), which sets special punishments for armed robbery, hijacking and piracy, makes murder on board a vessel under attack in the course of those offences punishable by death, bars bail for that offence, and provides for forfeiture of vessels and restraint and civil forfeiture of proceeds. The same day it passed the Visiting Forces Act 2008 (Act No. 6) and the Status of Visiting Police Forces Act 2008 (Act No. 7), which set the jurisdiction of Guyana’s courts over members of visiting armed and police forces from designated States; members of visiting police forces are immune from civil and criminal proceedings for acts in the course of their official duties, unless their State waives the immunity.
The Evidence and Motor Vehicles and Road Traffic (Amendment) Act 2008 (Act No. 10), passed on 25 July, creates an offence, punishable by a fine of $7,500, of driving or being in charge of a motor vehicle with alcohol in the breath or blood above the prescribed limit, with twelve months’ disqualification for two consecutive convictions and permanent disqualification on a third, and provides for certified evidence from speedometers, radar devices and weighing devices; it comes into force by ministerial order. The Prevention of Crimes (Amendment) Act 2008 (Act No. 11), passed the same day, places every person convicted on indictment under police supervision after serving the sentence, for one to three years depending on previous convictions, for three years after offences listed in Part I of a new Schedule, and for life after paedophile offences listed in Part II. On 24 July Parliament repealed section 16 of the Tax Act, and on 31 July it passed the Fiscal Enactments (Amendment) Act 2008, which allows the Minister to grant tax holidays of up to ten years, or longer for renewable energy projects, for new economic activity creating employment in listed regions and fields.
On 15 July, in Toolsie Persaud Ltd v Andrew James Investments Ltd [2008] CCJ 5 (AJ), the CCJ allowed in part the company’s appeal, reversing the courts below, which had dismissed its petition for prescriptive title to land the State had compulsorily acquired in 1977 and contracted to sell it in 1987. A person in possession who means to use land as an owner would has the necessary intention to possess, even if he wrongly believes he owns it; the State may also be an adverse possessor; and owners stop time running only by proceedings against the person in possession, not by constitutional motions against the State. The company was declared to have acquired title to the first respondent’s areas, succeeded against the second respondent subject to the state of the Register of Deeds, and failed as against the State.
On 22 July, in [2008] CCJ 6 (AJ), the CCJ dismissed an appeal by a purchaser who had paid for and occupied land under an agreement with his sister, who then passed transport to someone else. The Civil Law of Guyana Act and section 23(1) of the Deeds Registry Act recognise only full ownership, so equitable interests in land are not recognised or acquired in Guyana; the purchaser had only a right to sue for specific performance before transport passed, and the transferee took an indefeasible title open to attack only for fraud. The same day, in Trinidad Cement Ltd and TCL Guyana Inc v Guyana [2008] CCJ 1 (OJ), the CCJ’s first case in its original jurisdiction, the Court reserved its decision on the companies’ application for special leave and invited the Community and the other Contracting Parties to make submissions on whether a company incorporated or registered in a Contracting Party qualifies under article 222. It granted leave on 15 January 2009 (see January 2009).
From the Guyana Courts
On 31 July the Court of Appeal held the Guyana Revenue Authority’s grounds of appeal unmeritorious and dismissed the cross-appeal of Demerara Distillers Ltd, in a dispute over consumption tax on locally produced alcohol in which the High Court had quashed the Authority’s assessment. Under the Consumption Tax Act the Comptroller must determine the notional open market price at the time of appropriation or delivery, whichever is earlier. The Comptroller had wrongly adopted the company’s selling price, and the company had usurped his authority by fixing the value itself, so a new determination was required. A President’s view of the meaning of an Act he assented to may be persuasive but does not bind the court, and a legitimate expectation cannot arise against a statute.
The accounts of the Acts are taken from their texts as published by the Parliament of Guyana. The accounts of the CCJ decisions are taken from the CCJ’s judgments and the reports at [2008] GLR 183, 201 and 210, and that of the Court of Appeal decision from the report at [2008] GLR 221.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
