The CCJ gave reasons for refusing special leave to a former public servant; the Court of Appeal held that an amendment cannot turn a dismissal claim into a constitutional one and ordered a new hearing of a workshop injury claim.
On 27 June, in [2007] CCJ 4 (AJ), the CCJ gave its reasons for having refused, on 7 May, special leave to appeal and leave to appeal as a poor person to a former public servant. The Public Service Appellate Tribunal had no jurisdiction over his complaint once he was no longer under the control of the Public Service Commission, so the proposed appeal had no real prospect of success. No order was made as to costs.
From the Guyana Courts
On 20 June the Court of Appeal held that an amendment to the pleadings could not turn a private-law claim for unlawful dismissal into a constitutional matter. A police officer discharged in the public interest was entitled to 24 months’ salary, taking his duty to mitigate into account, and was eligible for a pension for his 17 years’ service, with interest; the appeal was allowed in part. The CCJ struck out his further appeal on 26 March 2008 (see March 2008).
The same day the Court of Appeal allowed an appeal by the owner of a goldsmith’s workshop against a finding that he was liable to an employee who was burned when a torch he had not been assigned exploded, and remitted the claim for a new hearing. The trial judge had not decided whether the defect that allowed gasoline vapour to escape could have been discovered with reasonable care, so the finding on causation could not stand.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the CCJ judgment and the reports at [2005-2007] GLR 317 and 223.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
