The Court of Appeal held that the power company could not back-bill for its own billing error, upheld a magistrate’s order returning gold to a dealer and set limits on interlocutory injunctions and specific performance.
From the Guyana Courts
On 11 March the Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by Guyana Power and Light Inc against a ruling of the Public Utilities Commission on complaints by three companies charged retroactively for underbilling. A consumer must pay for electricity reflected in bills based on approved rates, and section 7(2) of the Electricity Sector Reform Act 1999 allows a claim for up to six months only where no bill was tendered; it does not cover a supplier’s use of the wrong multiplier in bills already issued.
On 4 March the Court of Appeal, by a majority, restored a Chief Magistrate’s order that gold bars in police custody be returned to an authorised gold dealer who had reported them stolen. An application under section 69 of the Police Act need not be served on the Commissioner of Police, and once another High Court judge had ordered by mandamus that the magistrate’s order be obeyed, a judge could not quash it by certiorari without in effect sitting on appeal.
On 1 March the Court of Appeal held that an interlocutory injunction against trespass had been wrongly granted on the sole basis that the defendants said nothing about the plaintiff’s ability to pay damages, and on 9 March it set aside an order for specific performance because the trial judge had not considered whether the written agreement for the sale of 20 acres accurately reflected the parties’ earlier oral agreement for 10.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2005-2007] GLR 49, 1, 67 and 93.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
